The Spy House / Seabrook-Wilson House – Haunted Museum in Port Monmouth, New Jersey

The Spy House stands as one of New Jersey’s most notorious haunted locations. This weathered colonial structure overlooks the Raritan Bay with centuries of dark history.

Built in 1663, the building has witnessed wars, death, and espionage. Visitors and staff report numerous paranormal encounters within its aged walls.

The museum now operates as a historical site showcasing revolutionary war artifacts. However, its ghostly residents seem far more interested in making their presence known.

Paranormal investigators consider this location among America’s most actively haunted buildings. At least 30 different spirits allegedly roam the property today.

Historical Background

Thomas Whitlock constructed the Spy House in 1663 on sandy shores of Sandy Hook Bay. The original structure served as a simple family dwelling for early colonial settlers.

The Seabrook family purchased the property in the mid-1700s and expanded it considerably. They operated a bustling harbor-side tavern that attracted sailors and travelers throughout the region.

During the Revolutionary War, the building earned its infamous “Spy House” nickname through clandestine activities. British Loyalists allegedly used the tavern as a base for espionage operations against American forces.

Thomas Whitlock Jr. served as a British sympathizer and spy during the conflict. He gathered intelligence on American troop movements and passed information to British forces stationed nearby.

The Seabrook family maintained ownership for over two centuries despite the property’s dark reputation. They witnessed countless deaths, shipwrecks, and tragedies from their waterfront vantage point.

In 1968, the building opened as a museum showcasing local maritime and revolutionary war history. The structure has undergone minimal restoration, preserving its authentic colonial atmosphere and apparent spiritual inhabitants.

Paranormal Activity Summary

Visitors consistently report sudden temperature drops in specific rooms throughout the building. Cold spots appear without explanation, even during hot summer months when no air conditioning runs.

Disembodied footsteps echo across the creaking wooden floors when no one is present. Staff members hear distinct walking patterns moving room to room on upper floors while working alone.

Objects move independently throughout the museum displays with alarming frequency. Artifacts shift positions overnight, and locked doors mysteriously open between closing and morning checks.

Shadow figures dart along hallways and peer from darkened doorways at startled guests. These dark silhouettes lack definable features but move with obvious intention and purpose.

Electronic devices malfunction consistently within the building’s walls despite fresh batteries and proper maintenance. Cameras drain instantly, flashlights flicker, and recording equipment captures unexplained voices and sounds.

The scent of pipe tobacco and perfume manifests in empty rooms without any source. These phantom smells appear suddenly, linger for minutes, then vanish as mysteriously as they arrived.

Ghost Stories & Reports

Peter the Pirate remains the most famous spirit haunting the Spy House grounds. This bearded apparition appears wearing weathered seafaring clothes from the colonial period throughout the building.

Peter allegedly died during a violent confrontation at the tavern in the 1700s. His full-bodied apparition has been photographed multiple times, appearing as a solid figure before vanishing instantly.

Visitors report seeing Peter standing near windows overlooking the bay as if watching for ships. He sometimes appears in the tavern room, sitting at tables or standing near the fireplace.

The spirit of a young boy named Thomas haunts the museum’s upper floor. He died in the building under mysterious circumstances during the colonial era, possibly from illness.

Thomas playfully interacts with children visiting the museum, tugging on their clothes and whispering their names. Adults rarely see him, but his childish giggling echoes through empty rooms regularly.

A woman in white known as Abigail frequently appears in the upstairs bedroom area. Her identity remains uncertain, though some believe she was a Seabrook family member who died during childbirth.

Abigail’s ghost weeps softly in the darkness, her sobs heard clearly by overnight investigators. She appears as a translucent figure dressed in a flowing white nightgown, her face expressing profound sadness.

The Reverend manifests as a stern-looking man in dark clothing reminiscent of Puritan ministers. He appears disapproving of visitors, crossing his arms and staring with intense, judgmental eyes.

This spirit may be connected to religious services held in the building during its early years. He reportedly points accusingly at guests before fading away into walls or doorways.

A phantom British soldier in full Revolutionary War uniform patrols the museum’s exterior grounds. Witnesses describe his red coat and tricorn hat in remarkable detail before he vanishes mid-stride.

This soldier may represent one of the British troops who used the tavern during wartime. His apparition sometimes appears wounded, clutching his chest as if suffering from a fatal injury.

Most Haunted Spot

The upstairs bedroom section generates the most consistent paranormal activity within the building. Visitors experience overwhelming feelings of sadness and dread when entering this specific area alone.

Peter the Pirate appears most frequently in this room, standing near the windows or beside the antique bed. The temperature drops dramatically, often reading 15-20 degrees colder than surrounding spaces.

Investigators capture the highest concentration of EVP recordings in this bedroom during overnight sessions. Voices speak names, answer questions, and sometimes demand that visitors leave the premises immediately.

The basement area runs a close second for paranormal intensity and frightening encounters. This dark, cramped space housed smuggled goods and possibly hidden contraband during the tavern’s operational years.

Shadow figures move with startling speed through the basement’s low-ceilinged rooms. Many visitors refuse to enter this area after experiencing intense feelings of being watched or followed.

Can You Visit?

The Spy House operates as a public museum open for daytime visits seasonally. General admission is free, though donations are gratefully accepted to support building maintenance and preservation.

The museum typically opens on weekends from April through October, weather permitting. Hours vary, so calling ahead or checking their official schedule ensures the building is accessible.

Special paranormal investigation events occur throughout the year by reservation only. These after-hours sessions allow ghost hunters to explore the building with proper equipment and extended access.

Photography is fully permitted and actively encouraged throughout the museum’s interior and grounds. Many visitors capture unexplained anomalies, orbs, and apparent apparitions in their photographs and videos.

The Monmouth County Historical Association manages the property and coordinates all visitation schedules. Contact them directly for current hours, special events, and paranormal investigation booking information.

Best Time to Visit

Paranormal activity reportedly increases during evening hours after sunset when the museum closes. The spirits seem most active between 8 PM and 2 AM based on investigation reports.

October draws the highest concentration of supernatural encounters throughout the year. The autumn season amplifies paranormal energy, with multiple witnesses reporting simultaneous experiences during this period.

Stormy weather conditions seem to trigger heightened spiritual activity within the building. Investigators notice increased EVP responses and physical manifestations during electrical storms and heavy rain.

Anniversary dates connected to Revolutionary War events sometimes produce intense paranormal experiences. The spirits appear more agitated and active on historically significant dates from the 1770s.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

Museum curator Gertrude Neidlinger documented extensive paranormal activity during her tenure from 1962 to 1990. She maintained detailed logs of supernatural encounters, recording over 200 distinct incidents throughout her time.

Neidlinger reported seeing Peter the Pirate on numerous occasions while working alone. She described his bearded face and period clothing in consistent detail across multiple sightings.

In 1975, a group of school children on a field trip simultaneously witnessed a woman in white gliding across the upstairs hallway. Teachers confirmed the children’s accounts matched perfectly, describing identical details without collaboration.

Local police responded to multiple burglar alarms triggered at the museum with no signs of break-ins. Officers reported hearing footsteps and voices inside the locked building during these false alarm investigations.

A maintenance worker refused to return after encountering a shadow figure that rushed toward him in the basement. He described feeling intense cold and paralyzing fear during the aggressive encounter.

Paranormal researcher Dr. Hans Holzer investigated the Spy House extensively during the 1960s and 1970s. His published findings declared the location authentically haunted with multiple documented spirit presences.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

The Atlantic Paranormal Society featured the Spy House on their popular television series “Ghost Hunters.” Their investigation captured compelling EVP evidence and unexplained temperature fluctuations throughout the building.

TAPS team members experienced personal encounters including physical touches and disembodied voices. Their thermal imaging cameras recorded cold spots moving intelligently through rooms without natural explanation.

Multiple independent paranormal research teams have investigated the property with consistent results. Groups report similar experiences despite having no prior knowledge of specific haunting patterns or locations.

EMF meters spike dramatically in the upstairs bedroom and basement areas without electrical sources. These electromagnetic field fluctuations correspond with reported spiritual manifestations and eyewitness accounts.

Spirit box sessions yield intelligent responses that directly answer investigators’ specific questions. The voices identify themselves using historical names associated with the building’s documented past residents.

Full-spectrum photography captures numerous anomalies invisible to the naked eye throughout the structure. These images show apparent figures, mists, and light formations concentrated in historically active areas.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

The building’s aged structure contains uneven flooring, low doorways, and steep staircases requiring careful navigation. Visitors must watch their step, especially when focusing on paranormal investigation equipment rather than physical surroundings.

The basement area presents particular hazards with low ceilings and cramped spaces. Tall visitors should proceed cautiously to avoid head injuries on exposed wooden beams.

After-hours visits require official permission from the Monmouth County Historical Association management. Trespassing on the property outside authorized hours may result in criminal charges and prosecution.

The grounds sit near water with unstable banks that erode during storms and high tides. Visitors should remain on designated pathways and avoid approaching the bay’s edge, particularly during darkness.

Local Legends & Myths

Local folklore claims a treasure remains buried somewhere on the Spy House property. Pirates allegedly hid valuable plunder near the building, and its location died with them.

Some believe Peter the Pirate’s ghost remains earthbound because he guards this hidden treasure. His spirit supposedly becomes agitated when people search the grounds with metal detectors.

A persistent legend suggests secret tunnels connect the basement to the nearby shoreline. These passages allegedly allowed smugglers and spies to move contraband and intelligence without detection.

No tunnels have been definitively located despite numerous searches and investigations. However, the basement’s unusual construction features suggest possible concealed spaces or filled-in passages.

Stories circulate about a hanging that occurred on the property during the Revolutionary War. A convicted spy allegedly met his end from a tree that once stood near the building.

This execution may explain the soldier spirit’s wounded appearance and the property’s heavy, oppressive atmosphere. Historical records neither confirm nor completely disprove this dark tale’s authenticity.

Nearby Haunted Places

Proprietary House – Haunted Mansion in Perth Amboy, New Jersey

📍 10.3 miles

Merchant's House Museum – Haunted Historic House in Manhattan, New York

📍 20.6 miles

Morris-Jumel Mansion – Haunted Historic House in Manhattan, New York

📍 28.5 miles

The Devil's Tree – Haunted Oak Tree in Bernards Township, New Jersey

📍 28.9 miles

Lambert Castle – Haunted Castle in Paterson, New Jersey

📍 32.1 miles

112 Ocean Avenue House – Haunted House in Amityville, New York

📍 38.7 miles