Centenary University / Brotherton Hall – Haunted College Building in Hackettstown, New Jersey

Centenary University sits on a sprawling campus in the quiet town of Hackettstown, New Jersey. Among its many historic buildings, Brotherton Hall stands out as the most haunted location on campus. Students and faculty have reported paranormal encounters here for decades. The building’s dark history continues to attract ghost hunters and curious students alike.

Brotherton Hall isn’t just another college residence building with creaky floors. Strange occurrences have been documented since the early 1900s. The spirits that roam these halls seem to have unfinished business. Their presence has become an accepted part of campus life over the years.

Historical Background

Brotherton Hall was constructed in 1874 as part of the original Centenary Collegiate Institute. The Victorian-style building served as a women’s dormitory for nearly a century. Its thick stone walls and narrow hallways have witnessed generations of young women. The architecture reflects the strict moral standards of the post-Civil War era.

The building was named after the Brotherton family, prominent benefactors of the institution. Their generous donations helped establish Centenary as a Methodist educational facility. The family believed strongly in providing education for young women. Their legacy lives on in the building that bears their name.

A tragic event occurred in Brotherton Hall during the winter of 1892. A young student named Sarah Wilson died under mysterious circumstances in Room 214. She was found unconscious in her bed on a frigid January morning. Despite the efforts of local doctors, she never regained consciousness.

The official cause of death was listed as sudden illness. However, rumors circulated among students about what really happened that night. Some claimed Sarah had been practicing spiritualism with other students. Others whispered about a forbidden romance that ended in heartbreak.

The building underwent major renovations in 1968 after decades of wear. Workers reported strange occurrences during the construction period. Tools would disappear and reappear in different locations. Cold spots moved through rooms even during the hot summer months.

Paranormal Activity Summary

The most common paranormal occurrence in Brotherton Hall involves unexplained footsteps. Students regularly hear someone walking through empty hallways late at night. The footsteps always move in the same pattern, from Room 214 to the stairwell. They stop abruptly at the top of the main staircase.

Doors throughout the building open and close on their own with alarming frequency. The phenomenon occurs most often on the second floor near Room 214. Residents have installed multiple locks only to find doors wide open. Security cameras have captured doors moving with no visible cause.

Cold spots appear randomly throughout Brotherton Hall, defying logical explanation. These areas of intense cold measure up to thirty degrees lower than surrounding spaces. They move slowly through rooms as if an invisible presence is walking. Students report feeling watched when entering these cold zones.

Electronic devices malfunction regularly within the building’s walls. Cell phones drain completely within minutes despite being fully charged. Laptops shut down unexpectedly when students work on papers. The campus IT department has investigated but found no technical explanation.

A ghostly female figure has been seen on numerous occasions. She appears most frequently in second-floor hallways between midnight and 3 AM. Witnesses describe her as wearing a long white nightgown from the Victorian era. Her face appears sad and she seems to be searching for something.

Ghost Stories & Reports

Sarah Wilson is believed to be the primary spirit haunting Brotherton Hall. Students who have encountered her describe feeling overwhelming sadness in her presence. She appears as a young woman with long dark hair. Her expression suggests she’s lost and confused about her circumstances.

One particularly detailed encounter occurred in October 2015. Student Amanda Chen was studying alone in the second-floor common room. She heard soft crying coming from the hallway around 1 AM. When she investigated, she saw a translucent figure in white. The apparition turned toward her before fading away completely.

Room 214, Sarah’s former residence, experiences the most intense paranormal activity. Current residents report waking to find their belongings rearranged overnight. Personal items disappear and return days later in unusual places. One student found her jewelry box contents arranged in a perfect circle.

The room’s temperature drops dramatically without warning or apparent cause. Residents have measured sudden decreases of twenty to thirty degrees. These temperature changes last anywhere from five minutes to several hours. Heat sensors show the cold emanating from a specific corner of the room.

A second spirit, known only as “The Matron,” also haunts the building. She appears as an older woman dressed in early 1900s clothing. Students describe her as stern and disapproving in appearance. She’s most often seen on the first floor near the old resident advisor’s quarters.

The Matron seems to enforce rules from a bygone era. Students report feeling suddenly compelled to behave more formally in certain areas. Some have heard a woman’s voice scolding them for running in hallways. The voice speaks with old-fashioned phrases no longer in common use.

Legend says The Matron was a residence hall director who died in 1923. She allegedly suffered a fatal heart attack while breaking up a party. Her strict adherence to campus rules apparently carried over into the afterlife. Students jokingly refer to her as the “eternal RA.”

Shadow figures have been reported throughout Brotherton Hall for decades. These dark silhouettes move quickly along walls and through doorways. They appear solid enough to cast their own shadows. Witnesses say they seem aware of human presence and avoid direct confrontation.

The most unsettling reports involve students feeling invisible hands touching them. These encounters happen most frequently on the main staircase. Victims describe feeling fingers brushing their shoulders or arms. The touch feels ice cold and leaves no visible marks.

Most Haunted Spot

Room 214 on the second floor holds the distinction of most haunted location. This is where Sarah Wilson died under mysterious circumstances in 1892. Every student who has resided there reports at least one paranormal experience. The university no longer assigns first-year students to this particular room.

The room’s closet seems to be a focal point for activity. Students hear scratching sounds coming from inside when no one is there. Clothes are found torn from hangers and thrown on the floor. One resident installed a lock only to find it broken from the inside.

The second-floor bathroom adjacent to Room 214 also experiences intense phenomena. Faucets turn on by themselves during the night. Mirrors fog up spelling out indecipherable letters or symbols. Students avoid using this bathroom alone after dark when possible.

Can You Visit?

Brotherton Hall is not open to the general public as an active campus building. The building functions as student housing during the academic year. Unauthorized entry onto campus property constitutes trespassing. Campus security actively patrols the grounds throughout the night.

Centenary University occasionally hosts alumni events that include building tours. These tours typically occur during homecoming weekend in October. Registration is required and spaces fill quickly due to high demand. Photography is generally permitted during official university-sponsored tours.

The university does not officially acknowledge or promote the building’s haunted reputation. Administration prefers to focus on academic achievements and campus improvements. However, student tour guides often share ghost stories with prospective students. These unofficial accounts have become part of campus culture.

Paranormal investigation groups have been denied access to the building repeatedly. The university cites safety concerns and student privacy as primary reasons. Some former students have attempted to organize unofficial investigations after graduation. These attempts have been stopped by campus security.

Best Time to Visit

The most intense paranormal activity occurs during the academic year between September and May. Winter months, particularly January and February, see increased supernatural occurrences. This timing coincides with the anniversary of Sarah Wilson’s mysterious death. The cold weather seems to amplify the building’s haunted atmosphere.

Late night hours between midnight and 3 AM remain the most active period. Students living in Brotherton Hall report peak activity around 2:15 AM specifically. This exact time appears in multiple independent witness accounts over decades. October brings increased activity possibly due to the thinning veil between worlds.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

Former resident Jessica Martinez documented her experiences in Brotherton Hall during 2018. She kept a detailed journal of paranormal events in Room 214. Her account includes photographs of unexplained light anomalies and temperature readings. The journal was later shared on campus paranormal forums.

Jessica described waking one night to see Sarah’s ghost standing at the window. The apparition was staring out at the campus grounds below. When Jessica sat up in bed, the figure turned toward her. Jessica described feeling profound sadness wash over her before the ghost vanished.

Campus security officer Michael Torres worked the night shift for twelve years. He submitted multiple incident reports about strange occurrences in Brotherton Hall. His reports detail unexplained noises, moving shadows, and malfunctioning equipment. Torres eventually requested reassignment to other buildings citing the psychological toll.

In his most detailed report from March 2017, Torres described entering the building. He was responding to a noise complaint on the second floor. When he reached the landing, he saw a full-bodied apparition of a young woman. She looked directly at him before walking through a closed door.

Professor Elizabeth Hammond taught English classes in Centenary for thirty-five years. She lived in Brotherton Hall as a student in the 1970s. Hammond openly discusses her experiences with paranormal activity during that time. She believes Sarah Wilson is trying to communicate something important.

Hammond recalls hearing her name whispered in empty hallways multiple times. She also experienced the sudden cold spots that have become synonymous with the building. Her roommate once photographed what appears to be a misty figure in their room. The photograph has been analyzed by paranormal researchers with inconclusive results.

Local Legends & Myths

Local legend claims Sarah Wilson was pregnant when she died in 1892. This scandalous situation would have been devastating in the strict Methodist environment. Some believe she took her own life to avoid the shame. Others think she was murdered to protect someone’s reputation.

Another version of the story suggests Sarah died during a failed abortion attempt. Back-alley procedures were the only option for desperate young women in that era. The secrecy surrounding her death supports this theory. No autopsy report exists in official university records.

The Matron’s true identity remains a subject of debate among students. Some research suggests she was Margaret Worthington, a residence director from 1918-1923. Others believe she’s an amalgamation of several strict supervisors. Historical records show three different women held similar positions during that period.

A persistent urban legend claims a secret tunnel connects Brotherton Hall to other buildings. Students say The Matron’s ghost uses these tunnels to move around campus. While tunnels do exist for utilities, they’re sealed and inaccessible. The legend likely grew from maintenance corridors visible during renovations.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

An unofficial investigation was conducted by student paranormal enthusiasts in 2012. The group used EMF detectors and digital voice recorders throughout the building. They captured several EVPs that appeared to say “help me” and “cold.” Temperature fluctuations were documented with thermal imaging cameras.

The investigation team focused heavily on Room 214 and surrounding areas. They recorded unusual spikes in electromagnetic activity near the infamous closet. Motion sensors triggered repeatedly with no visible cause. The footage has circulated on paranormal websites and YouTube channels.

A professional paranormal investigation team from New York requested access in 2016. The team included experienced researchers with scientific equipment and methodology. Their formal proposal was rejected by university administration. They were cited for trespassing when they attempted to investigate anyway.

Despite the official rejection, team members shared preliminary findings online. They claimed to have documented Class A EVPs from outside the building. Thermal cameras allegedly captured heat signatures consistent with human forms in windows. The university threatened legal action if the footage was released publicly.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

Trespassing on Centenary University property carries serious legal consequences. Campus security works closely with local Hackettstown police to prosecute violators. Fines can reach several hundred dollars for unauthorized entry. Repeat offenders may face criminal charges beyond simple trespassing.

The building’s interior poses physical dangers beyond paranormal concerns. Old staircases have uneven steps that create tripping hazards. Some areas contain asbestos that was not fully remediated during renovations. Unauthorized visitors risk injury without knowledge of these dangerous areas.

Students living in Brotherton Hall sign agreements acknowledging the building’s condition. They’re advised to report any paranormal experiences to resident advisors. The university maintains this policy protects student wellbeing. Critics argue it’s primarily designed to minimize liability.

Photography from public areas outside the building is technically legal. However, campus security may ask photographers to leave university property. Drone photography over campus is explicitly prohibited by university policy. Violators will have equipment confiscated and may face trespassing charges.

Nearby Haunted Places

The Shades of Death Road – Haunted Road in Warren County, New Jersey

📍 5.9 miles

The Devil's Tree – Haunted Oak Tree in Bernards Township, New Jersey

📍 19.9 miles

Clinton Road – Haunted Road in West Milford, New Jersey

📍 24.5 miles

Historic Hotel Bethlehem – Haunted Hotel in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

📍 32.7 miles

Lambert Castle – Haunted Castle in Paterson, New Jersey

📍 34.8 miles

Ringwood Manor – Haunted Estate in Ringwood, New Jersey

📍 36.3 miles