The Story Inn – Haunted Hotel in Story, Indiana

Tucked away in the sleepy village of Story, Indiana, sits a charming bed and breakfast with a dark past. The Story Inn has welcomed guests since the 1850s, but not all visitors have checked out. This rustic establishment has earned a reputation as one of Indiana’s most actively haunted locations. Guests and staff report unexplained phenomena almost daily, from phantom footsteps to full-bodied apparitions.

The inn’s weathered exterior and creaky interior create the perfect atmosphere for ghostly encounters. Over the decades, countless people have experienced unexplained events within these historic walls. Some visitors come specifically hoping to encounter the supernatural residents who call this place home. The Story Inn continues operating as a functioning hotel, restaurant, and bar despite its haunted reputation.

Story, Indiana itself is nearly a ghost town with a population of less than twenty people. The tiny hamlet reached its peak in the late 1800s when it served as a bustling general store community. Today, the Story Inn stands as the last remaining business in this forgotten settlement. The isolation and history make it a magnet for those seeking authentic paranormal experiences.

Historical Background

The Story Inn building was constructed in 1851 by Dr. George Story, the town’s founder and physician. He built the original structure to serve as a general store and boarding house for travelers. The two-story building became the commercial and social heart of the small community that grew around it. Dr. Story ran his medical practice from the building while his family operated the general store.

The town of Story thrived throughout the late 1800s, supporting several businesses and a schoolhouse. A devastating fire in 1916 destroyed most of the village, leaving only a handful of structures standing. The general store building survived but the community never fully recovered from the disaster. By the 1920s, Story had become a virtual ghost town with most residents moving to larger communities.

The building changed hands multiple times throughout the twentieth century, falling into disrepair during several periods. In 1943, the structure was converted into a restaurant and small inn for tourists. The property underwent extensive renovations in the 1970s to restore its historical character. Current owners have maintained the building’s nineteenth-century charm while adding modern amenities for overnight guests.

Several tragedies occurred on the property during its long history, contributing to its haunted reputation. A woman named Rachel died in the building under mysterious circumstances in the early 1900s. Local records suggest she may have been a victim of foul play, though details remain unclear. Her death is just one of several suspicious incidents documented at this location over the decades.

The inn sits on land that was originally dense Indiana forest inhabited by Native American tribes. Some researchers believe the property may have spiritual significance predating European settlement. Objects and artifacts discovered during renovations suggest the site had human activity going back centuries. This layered history may contribute to the intense paranormal activity reported at the location.

Paranormal Activity Summary

Guests at the Story Inn report an impressive variety of supernatural phenomena throughout the building. Disembodied footsteps echo through hallways when no one is present, following distinct patterns up and down stairs. Objects move on their own, with items disappearing from one location and reappearing in another. Cold spots manifest suddenly in specific rooms, dropping temperatures by twenty degrees or more.

Shadow figures appear frequently, particularly in the upstairs guest rooms and main dining area. Witnesses describe human-shaped shadows moving across walls and through doorways with purposeful motion. These entities often appear in peripheral vision, vanishing when observers turn to look directly at them. Some guests report feeling an unseen presence watching them from darkened corners of rooms.

Phantom smells permeate certain areas of the inn without any identifiable source. The scent of lavender perfume wafts through the Blue Lady Room despite no flowers being present. Cigar smoke appears in the bar area even though smoking has been prohibited for decades. Kitchen staff report the smell of baking bread in the early morning hours before ovens are lit.

Electronic devices malfunction with unusual frequency throughout the building, particularly cameras and recording equipment. Batteries drain completely within minutes of entering specific rooms, even when fully charged. Cell phones register strange interference and display cryptic error messages. Guests attempting to photograph certain areas find their images distorted with unexplained lights and shadows.

Unexplained knocking and rapping sounds occur throughout the night in various guest rooms. The knocks follow intelligent patterns, sometimes responding to questions posed by curious visitors. Doors open and close on their own, sometimes slamming violently despite no drafts or wind. Windows rattle without explanation, and doorknobs turn as if invisible hands are testing the locks.

Ghost Stories & Reports

The most famous spirit at the Story Inn is known as the Blue Lady. She appears as a woman dressed in a long blue Victorian-era dress with her hair styled in a period-appropriate bun. Witnesses describe her as semi-transparent, with sad eyes that seem to plead for help. The Blue Lady has been seen by hundreds of guests over the decades, making her the inn’s primary paranormal resident.

Most researchers believe the Blue Lady is Rachel, the woman who died mysteriously in the early 1900s. According to local legend, Rachel was staying at the inn when she fell violently ill. Dr. Story’s successor treated her but could not save her life, and she died in what is now the Blue Lady Room. Some accounts suggest she was poisoned, though official records list her death as natural causes.

Rachel appears most frequently in Room 5, now officially designated the Blue Lady Room. Guests report seeing her standing near the window, gazing out at the street below. She sometimes sits on the edge of the bed, and visitors wake to find an indentation in the mattress beside them. Her manifestations often coincide with the smell of lavender, apparently her favorite perfume in life.

A male spirit known simply as “The General” haunts the bar and dining areas downstairs. Staff members describe him as a tall man wearing what appears to be a Civil War era military uniform. He appears solid and lifelike until he walks through walls or vanishes before witnesses’ eyes. The General seems interested in the bar’s operations, often appearing when bottles are being moved or inventoried.

Local folklore suggests The General was a Confederate officer who passed through Story during or shortly after the Civil War. Some accounts claim he was wounded and died while recuperating at the inn. Others suggest he was a deserter who hid in Story and took his own life. His identity remains one of the location’s greatest mysteries, as no historical records confirm his existence.

The General interacts with the physical environment more than any other spirit at the inn. Bartenders report bottles moving on their own, sometimes sliding across the bar or falling from shelves. Chairs rearrange themselves overnight, forming deliberate patterns that staff discover each morning. The General allegedly has a favorite seat at the bar where a cold spot permanently resides. Patrons who sit in this spot often report feeling extremely uncomfortable and move to other seats.

A child spirit, believed to be a young girl around seven or eight years old, manifests in the upstairs hallway. Guests hear the sound of a child giggling and running through the corridor late at night. The little girl appears briefly, dressed in a white nightgown, before disappearing through closed doors. She seems playful rather than threatening, though her presence startles many visitors who weren’t expecting to see a ghost.

This child spirit reportedly died of illness in the 1880s while her family was staying at the inn. The harsh winter and lack of proper medical care claimed many young lives in rural Indiana during that era. She appears most frequently during winter months, perhaps an anniversary haunting tied to her death. Some guests report hearing her calling for her mother in a small, frightened voice.

An unidentified male entity haunts the basement and storage areas beneath the inn. This spirit exhibits more aggressive behavior than the other ghosts, creating a sense of menace and unease. Workers avoid the basement when possible, reporting feelings of being pushed or grabbed by invisible hands. This entity seems territorial, as if protecting something hidden in the building’s foundation.

Most Haunted Spot

Room 5, officially known as the Blue Lady Room, experiences the most intense and frequent paranormal activity at the inn. Guests in this room report waking to find the Blue Lady standing at the foot of their bed. The mattress depresses as if someone is sitting on it, and the temperature drops dramatically without warning. Personal belongings move around the room overnight, and guests often hear a woman crying softly near the window.

The basement ranks as the second most actively haunted area, though it’s off-limits to most guests. Staff members working in storage areas report overwhelming feelings of dread and being watched. Shadow figures move through the darkness down there, and disembodied voices whisper threats. Several employees have refused to go to the basement alone after experiencing unexplained phenomena in this isolated space.

Can You Visit?

The Story Inn is open to the public and actively welcomes overnight guests year-round. Room rates range from approximately one hundred to two hundred dollars per night depending on season and accommodation. The Blue Lady Room can be specifically requested by guests hoping for paranormal encounters. Reservations are recommended, especially during October when paranormal enthusiasts flock to the location.

The inn’s restaurant and bar are open to walk-in visitors who aren’t staying overnight. Dining guests can explore the main floor and often experience paranormal activity during their meals. The staff is friendly and willing to share ghost stories with interested visitors. Photography is allowed throughout the public areas and in guest rooms during stays.

No formal ghost tours are offered, but the innkeepers provide informal paranormal briefings to interested guests. They share the building’s history and direct visitors to the most active locations. Overnight guests are free to explore and conduct their own investigations throughout the building. Many paranormal investigation groups have received permission to spend nights at the inn conducting formal research.

Best Time to Visit

Paranormal activity occurs year-round at the Story Inn, but certain periods see increased manifestations. October through December brings heightened activity, with guests reporting more frequent encounters during autumn months. The anniversary of Rachel’s death in March also corresponds with increased Blue Lady sightings. Cold winter nights seem to amplify the spiritual energy throughout the building.

Activity levels peak during the late night and early morning hours between midnight and four AM. The Blue Lady appears most frequently around three AM, often referred to as the witching hour. Weekend nights tend to be more active than weekdays, possibly due to increased energy from more guests. Full moon periods coincide with reports of more intense and dramatic paranormal events throughout the inn.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

A couple from Indianapolis reported waking at exactly three AM to find the Blue Lady standing beside their bed in Room 5. The husband attempted to take a photograph, but his phone died instantly despite being fully charged. The apparition reached toward them before fading away, leaving the room ice cold. They described feeling profound sadness wash over them during the encounter, as if experiencing the ghost’s emotions.

A skeptical businessman staying at the inn in 2015 documented his experience in an online review. He checked in not believing the ghost stories and specifically requested the Blue Lady Room. At two AM, he woke to find all his belongings stacked in a neat pile in the center of the room. His suitcase had been opened and clothes folded, though he clearly remembered leaving items scattered around the space.

Restaurant staff members have shared numerous accounts of encounters with The General in the bar area. One waitress reported seeing a tall man in period clothing sitting at the bar after closing. She approached to inform him the restaurant was closed, only to watch him vanish into thin air. The same employee later experienced bottles falling from shelves when she was alone in the bar, hearing a male voice laugh.

A paranormal investigation team from Purdue University spent three nights at the inn conducting research in 2018. They recorded multiple EVP sessions capturing clear voices responding to their questions in various rooms. Their thermal imaging cameras detected human-shaped cold spots moving through hallways. The team’s final report concluded the location showed strong evidence of genuine paranormal activity across multiple detection methods.

A family with young children stayed at the inn and reported their daughter having conversations with invisible friends. The child insisted a little girl in a white nightgown was playing with her in the hallway. She provided specific details about the ghost child’s appearance that matched historical descriptions. The parents were unnerved but the daughter seemed delighted, asking to return to play with her “new friend.”

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

Multiple professional paranormal investigation teams have studied the Story Inn over the past three decades. The location has gained respect in the ghost hunting community for its consistent and verifiable activity. Teams using various detection methods have documented unexplained phenomena that defies conventional explanation. The accumulation of evidence from independent sources strengthens the case for genuine haunting activity.

EVP recordings captured at the inn have yielded some of the clearest spirit voices on record. Investigators recorded a female voice saying “help me” in the Blue Lady Room during an overnight session. A male voice responding to direct questions was captured in the bar area. These recordings have been analyzed by audio experts who confirm the voices aren’t the result of radio interference or other mundane sources.

Electromagnetic field detectors register unusual spikes in specific locations throughout the building without identifiable electrical sources. The Blue Lady Room shows consistent EMF anomalies near the window where Rachel’s ghost frequently appears. The basement generates readings that suggest intense electromagnetic activity concentrated in specific spots. These patterns remain consistent across multiple investigations years apart, suggesting permanent energy signatures in the location.

Thermal imaging has captured dramatic temperature drops occurring suddenly in haunted rooms during investigations. Cameras recorded a human-shaped cold spot moving across the Blue Lady Room, dropping from seventy-two degrees to forty-eight degrees. The cold spot moved intelligently, seeming to respond to investigators’ presence. Similar temperature anomalies have been documented in the bar area during manifestations of The General.

Though not featured on major television programs, the Story Inn has been documented in several paranormal investigation documentaries and podcasts. The location’s remote setting and authentic haunting make it attractive to serious researchers rather than entertainment-focused productions. Local paranormal groups regularly include the inn in their investigations and tours of southern Indiana haunted locations. The growing body of documented evidence continues to enhance the location’s reputation in paranormal research circles.

Local Legends & Myths

Local folklore includes tales of underground tunnels beneath Story Inn connected to the Underground Railroad. Some believe spirits of escaped slaves who found refuge or died in Story still linger in the basement. No historical evidence confirms these tunnels exist, but the legend persists among area residents. The aggressive male entity in the basement is sometimes attributed to these Underground Railroad connections.

Another persistent legend claims the inn sits on a Native American burial ground or sacred site. Some paranormal researchers suggest this explains the layered spiritual activity occurring at multiple time periods. Local tribes including the Miami and Delaware peoples inhabited this region for centuries before European settlement. Whether the site held special significance to these cultures remains a matter of speculation and debate.

Stories circulate about a curse placed on the building after Dr. Story allegedly mistreated a patient. According to this legend, a dying woman cursed the doctor and his establishment before passing away. The curse supposedly doomed the building to be forever haunted by those who died within its walls. This tale lacks historical documentation but has been passed down through generations of Story residents.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

The Story Inn is private property and trespassing is strictly prohibited for non-guests. Visitors must book accommodations or visit during restaurant hours to access the building legally. The surrounding village of Story is mostly private property, so respectful behavior is essential when visiting. Violating these boundaries can result in prosecution and damages the location’s relationship with paranormal tourism.

The building’s age means stairs are steep and floors are uneven in some areas. Guests should exercise caution when moving through the inn, especially at night in darkened hallways. The basement is off-limits to guests due to safety concerns and structural issues. Anyone experiencing overwhelming fear or anxiety during paranormal encounters should immediately exit the area and seek support.

Nearby Haunted Places

Stepp Cemetery – Haunted Cemetery in Bloomington, Indiana

📍 18.8 miles

Hannah House – Haunted Mansion in Indianapolis, Indiana

📍 42.5 miles

Central State Hospital – Haunted Asylum in Indianapolis, Indiana

📍 46.3 miles

James Whitcomb Riley House – Haunted Museum in Indianapolis, Indiana

📍 46.7 miles

Avon Haunted Bridge – Haunted Bridge in Avon, Indiana

📍 46.8 miles

Culbertson Mansion – Haunted Mansion in New Albany, Indiana

📍 60.2 miles