St. Gertrude’s Monastery – Haunted Monastery in Cottonwood, Idaho

Nestled in the rolling hills of north-central Idaho sits St. Gertrude’s Monastery, a sacred place with secrets. This Benedictine monastery has stood watch over the Camas Prairie since the late 1800s. Visitors come seeking spiritual peace and quiet reflection among the monastery’s historic buildings. But some leave with stories of unexplained encounters that challenge their understanding of the physical world.

The sprawling complex includes multiple buildings spanning different architectural eras and purposes. Gothic arches meet modern additions in a fascinating blend of old and new construction. The monastery remains an active religious community today, with nuns continuing their sacred work. Yet beneath the surface of daily prayers and routine, something else lingers in the shadows.

Reports of paranormal activity have emerged from visitors, guests, and even the sisters themselves over decades. Strange sounds echo through empty corridors late at night when everyone should be asleep. Unexplained figures appear in windows of buildings that stand vacant and locked. The monastery’s long history holds tales of tragedy, devotion, and mysterious deaths that may explain the hauntings.

St. Gertrude’s isn’t your typical ghost story location filled with violence and gore. Instead, the spirits here seem drawn to the place by deep spiritual connections. The monastery grounds carry an energy that sensitive visitors describe as both peaceful and unsettling. Whatever walks these halls seems bound to the monastery by faith, duty, or unfinished business.

Historical Background

St. Gertrude’s Monastery was established in 1920 by Benedictine sisters from Switzerland. The nuns arrived in Idaho seeking to build a spiritual community and school. They constructed the main monastery building using local materials and European architectural designs. The structure’s stone walls and Gothic elements reflected their homeland’s religious architecture.

Before the current monastery existed, the sisters operated from a smaller wooden structure nearby. That original building burned down in 1925, claiming valuable religious artifacts and historical documents. One elderly sister named Sister Maria Theresa perished in the flames. Her body was found in the chapel, kneeling in prayer despite the inferno around her.

The monastery complex expanded significantly throughout the 20th century with additional buildings and facilities. A museum was added in 1982 to house the monastery’s collection of historical artifacts. The Chapel of St. Gertrude became a focal point, featuring stunning stained glass windows. Guest rooms were constructed to accommodate retreatants seeking spiritual renewal and quiet contemplation.

St. Gertrude’s also operated a boarding school for girls from 1920 until 1970. Hundreds of young women received their education within these walls during those fifty years. The school building still stands on the property, though it no longer serves students. Former students sometimes return for reunions, and some report feeling watched in their old dormitories.

A tragic incident occurred in 1963 when a young student named Margaret Sullivan disappeared from campus. Search parties combed the surrounding fields and forests for three agonizing weeks. Her body was eventually discovered in an old root cellar beneath the dormitory building. The official cause of death was listed as accidental, though questions remain about the circumstances.

Paranormal Activity Summary

The most commonly reported phenomenon at St. Gertrude’s involves the sound of chanting or singing. Witnesses hear what sounds like Gregorian chants coming from the chapel at odd hours. These ethereal voices continue even when investigators confirm no one physically occupies the space. The chanting typically occurs between 2:00 AM and 4:00 AM, the traditional hours of Lauds.

Cold spots plague several areas of the monastery, particularly near the old school dormitories. Visitors experience sudden temperature drops of 15 to 20 degrees without any logical explanation. These cold zones move and shift, appearing in different locations on different nights. Some guests report feeling as though they’ve walked through an invisible presence.

Shadow figures are frequently observed moving through the museum’s second floor exhibition rooms. These dark silhouettes appear humanoid but lack distinguishing features or clear definition. They seem to glide rather than walk, moving purposefully between display cases. Witnesses describe feeling profound sadness or melancholy when these shadows pass nearby.

Objects in the museum have been found rearranged despite strict security and locked doors. Religious artifacts sometimes appear moved from their designated spots overnight without human intervention. Museum staff members have documented these occurrences through photographs and written logs. Security cameras have mysteriously malfunctioned during periods when objects were being relocated.

The scent of incense and burning candles manifests in areas where no such materials exist. This phantom fragrance appears suddenly and dissipates just as quickly without any discernible source. The smell is particularly strong near the location where the original wooden monastery once stood. Some visitors also report the distinct aroma of baking bread, possibly from the old bakery.

Ghost Stories & Reports

Sister Maria Theresa remains the monastery’s most frequently encountered spirit despite her death in 1925. Witnesses describe seeing an elderly nun in old-fashioned habit kneeling in the chapel. She appears completely solid and lifelike until she suddenly vanishes without standing or moving. Her apparition always appears in the same spot where she reportedly died in prayer.

Several guests have reported full conversations with Sister Maria Theresa before realizing she wasn’t alive. She allegedly offers spiritual guidance and comfort to troubled visitors seeking answers. One woman in 2015 claimed the nun helped her find peace after her husband’s death. When the woman tried to thank her later, current sisters confirmed no such nun existed.

Margaret Sullivan, the student who died in 1963, haunts the old dormitory building extensively. Former students and maintenance workers report seeing a young girl in a 1960s school uniform. She appears confused and distressed, wandering the hallways as if searching for something. Some witnesses hear her calling out for help in a frightened, desperate voice.

A custodian named Frank Morrison had a terrifying encounter with Margaret’s spirit in 1998. He was cleaning the third-floor dormitory when he heard crying from an empty room. Upon entering Room 312, he saw Margaret sitting on a bed, tears streaming down her face. She looked directly at him and whispered “I couldn’t find the door” before fading away.

The monastery grounds are home to a spectral monk who appears in the gardens. This figure wears brown robes unlike the black habits worn by St. Gertrude’s sisters. He tends to plants and flowers that no longer exist in the current garden layout. Researchers speculate he might be connected to a Franciscan mission that briefly operated nearby in 1890.

An unidentified woman in white has been photographed near the old cemetery on monastery grounds. She appears in dozens of pictures taken by different people over the past thirty years. The woman stands among the headstones, her face obscured by the angle or lighting. No one has ever seen her with the naked eye during these photographic incidents.

Local folklore tells of a Native American woman who appears during full moons near the property’s boundaries. The land belonged to the Nez Perce tribe before European settlement and missionary work. Some believe she’s a guardian spirit protecting sacred ground that predates the monastery. She’s described as translucent, wearing traditional dress and carrying what appears to be a bundle.

Most Haunted Spot

Room 312 in the old dormitory building stands as the most intensely haunted location. This is where Margaret Sullivan lived before her mysterious death in 1963. Guests who sleep in this room during retreats report overwhelming feelings of sadness and anxiety. Many wake at exactly 3:17 AM experiencing difficulty breathing and sensing an oppressive presence.

The root cellar where Margaret’s body was discovered runs a close second for paranormal intensity. Modern visitors are not typically allowed access to this sealed underground space. Maintenance workers who’ve entered report hearing scratching sounds on the walls and desperate whimpering. Some have fled in terror, refusing to return regardless of their job duties.

The museum’s second floor, particularly the religious artifacts section, experiences consistent supernatural activity. Display cases vibrate and rattle without any physical cause or seismic activity. Visitors feel compelled to leave this area, experiencing an inexplicable fight-or-flight response. Several people have fainted in this section without any underlying medical conditions.

Can You Visit?

Yes, St. Gertrude’s Monastery welcomes visitors throughout the year for spiritual retreats and museum tours. The monastery operates as both an active religious community and a historical site. Guest rooms are available for overnight stays, though advance reservations are strongly recommended. The sisters maintain a policy of hospitality while respecting the property’s sacred nature.

The museum charges a small suggested donation of five dollars for self-guided tours. Guided tours are available by appointment for groups of six or more people. The museum operates Tuesday through Saturday from 9:30 AM to 4:30 PM. Sunday hours accommodate visitors after morning Mass, typically opening at 1:00 PM.

Photography is permitted in most public areas including the museum and chapel with certain restrictions. Flash photography is prohibited in the chapel during services and quiet reflection times. The dormitory building is not open for casual public tours due to safety concerns. Special access can sometimes be arranged through the monastery office for serious researchers.

Overnight retreat guests pay between 60 and 90 dollars depending on room selection and meal plans. Private rooms with private baths cost more than traditional shared accommodations. All guests must respect quiet hours from 9:00 PM to 7:00 AM. The sisters request that visitors maintain the contemplative atmosphere even during daytime hours.

Best Time to Visit

Paranormal activity at St. Gertrude’s appears most concentrated during the winter months between November and February. The long, dark nights of Idaho winters seem to amplify spiritual energy on the property. Many significant encounters have occurred during December, particularly around the Christmas season. Staff members note increased activity during religious feast days throughout the liturgical calendar.

The hours between 2:00 AM and 4:00 AM represent peak activity times for supernatural phenomena. This corresponds with traditional monastic prayer hours observed for centuries by Benedictine communities. Guests staying overnight report the highest frequency of unexplained sounds and apparitions during these hours. Those seeking paranormal experiences should request rooms in the older sections of the complex.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

Dr. Patricia Henderson, a theology professor from Portland, documented her experience during a 2012 retreat. She awoke at 2:45 AM to see a nun standing beside her bed in Room 218. The figure appeared solid and three-dimensional, watching her with kind but sorrowful eyes. When Dr. Henderson sat up to speak, the nun smiled and slowly faded into transparency.

A maintenance supervisor named Robert Chen recorded strange sounds in the dormitory building in 2018. His audio equipment captured what sounds like multiple young girls laughing and talking. The recordings were made at 11:00 PM when the building was confirmed empty and locked. Voice analysis experts couldn’t identify the source or explain the audio’s presence on his recordings.

Former student Diane Keller returned to St. Gertrude’s in 2006 for a reunion event. She visited her old room and encountered what she believes was Margaret Sullivan’s ghost. The apparition stood at the window, staring out at the grounds with her back turned. When Diane said hello, the figure turned partially, revealing a pale, sad face before vanishing.

In 2019, a photographer named Marcus Webb captured remarkable images during a museum visit. His pictures show distinct orbs of light moving in consistent patterns across multiple frames. Professional photo analysts confirmed the images were not manipulated or caused by dust particles. The orbs appear to demonstrate intelligent movement, avoiding obstacles and following specific pathways.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

The Pacific Northwest Paranormal Research Society conducted a formal investigation in October 2014. The team recorded extensive EVP evidence throughout the monastery, particularly in the old dormitory. Several voice recordings contain clear whispers of “help me” and “find the door.” Temperature fluctuations of up to 22 degrees were documented in Room 312 without environmental causes.

EMF meters registered unusual spikes in electromagnetic energy near the original monastery foundation site. These readings appeared in patterns rather than random fluctuations, suggesting intelligent manipulation. The investigation team concluded that St. Gertrude’s exhibits genuine paranormal activity warranting further study. Their full report remains available through the monastery’s historical archives by request.

Ghost Adventures briefly considered filming at St. Gertrude’s in 2016 but ultimately chose another location. The sisters expressed concerns about maintaining the monastery’s spiritual atmosphere during aggressive ghost hunting. However, several independent paranormal investigators have documented compelling evidence at the site. YouTube and various paranormal websites feature numerous amateur investigations with intriguing results.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

The monastery strictly prohibits unauthorized access to certain areas including the sealed root cellar. The old dormitory building has structural concerns in some sections, making unsupervised exploration dangerous. Visitors must obtain explicit permission before entering any locked or restricted areas. Trespassing after hours can result in local law enforcement involvement and potential charges.

Those experiencing health issues should exercise caution during overnight stays in allegedly haunted rooms. Several guests have reported panic attacks and anxiety-related symptoms during paranormal encounters. The monastery maintains contact information for local emergency services and mental health resources. Visitors with heart conditions should inform staff before requesting accommodation in high-activity areas.

Winter visits require proper preparation due to Idaho’s harsh weather and remote location. The monastery sits several miles from the nearest town with limited cell phone reception. Guests should bring appropriate clothing and inform someone of their travel plans. Snow and ice can make the roads dangerous between November and March.

Cursed or Haunted Objects

The museum houses a 19th-century crucifix that allegedly moves on its own accord. This wooden cross was brought from Switzerland by the founding sisters in 1920. Multiple witnesses have observed it rotating on its display mount despite being secured in place. The crucifix was reportedly present during the 1925 fire and survived without any burn damage.

A particular book of prayers in the museum’s collection refuses to stay closed overnight. Staff members place it shut each evening, but find it open to specific pages by morning. The pages typically show prayers for the dead or passages about purgatory and salvation. This phenomenon has continued consistently for over fifteen years without explanation or mechanical cause.

Nearby Haunted Places

Lewiston Historic Preservation Commission – Haunted Historic District in Lewiston, Idaho

📍 38.7 miles

Hot Lake Springs – Haunted Hotel in La Grande, Oregon

📍 93.3 miles

The Jameson Hotel – Haunted Hotel in Wallace, Idaho

📍 101.9 miles

Geiser Grand Hotel – Haunted Hotel in Baker City, Oregon

📍 111.4 miles

Kootenai County Jail – Haunted Detention Center in Coeur d'Alene, Idaho

📍 118.1 miles

The Egyptian Theatre – Haunted Theater in Boise, Idaho

📍 167.4 miles