Addy Sea Bed & Breakfast – Haunted Inn in Bethany Beach, Delaware

The Addy Sea Bed & Breakfast stands as a Victorian jewel along Delaware’s quiet coastline. This charming inn offers oceanfront views and elegant accommodations that hide a darker secret.

Guests who check in expecting a peaceful seaside retreat often encounter something far more unsettling. The spirits of former residents apparently never checked out of this beautiful beachfront property.

Built over a century ago, this historic building has witnessed countless summers and winters by the sea. The waves crashing outside aren’t the only disturbances guests report hearing at night.

The Addy Sea’s reputation as one of Delaware’s most haunted locations continues to grow each year. Paranormal enthusiasts and unsuspecting vacationers alike have documented unexplained phenomena within its walls.

Historical Background

The structure that houses Addy Sea was originally constructed in 1902 as a private beach cottage. John M. Addy built this grand seaside home for his family’s summer retreats.

The Addy family used the property as their personal vacation residence for several decades. The house witnessed multiple generations of family gatherings, celebrations, and personal tragedies.

In 1982, the property underwent significant renovations to transform it into a bed and breakfast. The original architectural charm was preserved while modernizing the interior spaces for guest accommodations.

The inn officially opened to paying guests in the mid-1980s under new ownership. Previous owners and guests immediately began reporting strange occurrences that couldn’t be easily explained.

A devastating fire struck a portion of the building during the renovation period in the early 1980s. Some paranormal researchers believe this traumatic event may have intensified spiritual activity on the property.

The property has changed hands several times over the past four decades. Each new owner has inherited not just the building but also its permanent supernatural residents.

Paranormal Activity Summary

Guests frequently report unexplained footsteps echoing through the second-floor hallway during late-night hours. These footsteps sound deliberate and purposeful, as if someone is making their nightly rounds.

Cold spots appear randomly throughout the building, even during hot summer months when air conditioning doesn’t explain the temperature drops. These icy patches often move slowly through rooms as if accompanying an invisible presence.

Doors throughout the inn open and close on their own with no discernible draft or mechanical explanation. Multiple witnesses have watched door handles turn by themselves before doors swing wide open.

Electronic equipment malfunctions with remarkable frequency inside certain rooms and common areas. Cell phones drain completely within minutes, and cameras often fail to function properly.

The scent of perfume and pipe tobacco manifests suddenly in various locations throughout the building. These phantom smells disappear as quickly as they arrive, leaving guests confused and unsettled.

Objects frequently relocate themselves overnight, appearing in completely different rooms from where they were left. Staff members have reported finding guest belongings neatly arranged in places no living person could have accessed.

Shadow figures are regularly spotted moving past doorways and through walls in the peripheral vision of guests. When witnesses turn to look directly at these shapes, they vanish instantly.

Ghost Stories & Reports

The most frequently encountered spirit is believed to be that of John M. Addy himself. Guests describe seeing an elderly gentleman in Victorian-era clothing standing near the ocean-facing windows.

John appears to be watching the waves, just as he did during his lifetime summer vacations. He seems peaceful and non-threatening, though his sudden appearances have startled numerous overnight visitors.

A female spirit wearing a long white nightgown has been spotted in several second-floor bedrooms. Witnesses describe her as appearing sad or distressed, often wringing her hands nervously.

This ghostly woman is believed to be Catherine Addy, John’s wife who died unexpectedly at the property. Historical records indicate she suffered a fatal heart attack during a summer visit in 1912.

Catherine’s spirit seems particularly active in Room 4, which was reportedly her favorite bedroom during family stays. Guests sleeping in this room often wake to the sensation of someone sitting on their bed.

The spirit of a young child has been heard but rarely seen throughout the building. Giggling and the sound of small feet running across wooden floors occur most frequently on weekend evenings.

Several guests have reported waking to find a small handprint on the bathroom mirror that wasn’t there before. The handprint is always positioned at a height consistent with a child around five or six years old.

Local folklore suggests this may be the spirit of the Addys’ grandson who drowned near the property. Historical documentation confirms a tragic drowning incident involving a family member occurred in 1925.

A darker presence reportedly inhabits the basement storage areas beneath the main building. Staff members refuse to go downstairs alone after experiencing overwhelming feelings of dread and hostility.

This malevolent entity is described as a heavy, oppressive presence that makes breathing difficult. Some psychic investigators believe this spirit is not connected to the Addy family at all.

One theory suggests this basement entity may be connected to the property’s previous use before the Addys purchased it. Research into earlier land ownership has revealed the site once included workers’ quarters with a tragic history.

Most Haunted Spot

Room 4 on the second floor experiences the most concentrated paranormal activity in the entire building. This oceanfront bedroom was Catherine Addy’s personal favorite, and she appears most frequently here.

Guests staying in Room 4 report waking between 2 and 3 AM to see a woman standing near the window. She gazes out at the ocean before slowly fading from view over approximately thirty seconds.

The rocking chair in Room 4 moves on its own even when no one is present. Security cameras have captured footage of the chair rocking gently for extended periods with no explanation.

Personal belongings in this room are frequently rearranged overnight into neat, orderly patterns. Women’s jewelry is often found carefully laid out on the dresser despite being left in suitcases.

The bathroom attached to Room 4 features a clawfoot tub where guests report hearing water running mysteriously. Upon investigation, the fixtures are always completely turned off and no water has actually run.

Can You Visit?

The Addy Sea Bed & Breakfast is open to the public as a fully operational lodging establishment. Guests can book rooms directly through the inn’s website or various travel booking platforms.

Room rates vary seasonally, typically ranging from $150 to $350 per night depending on the season. The most haunted Room 4 often books months in advance due to its paranormal reputation.

The inn does not offer specific paranormal tours to non-guests for liability and privacy reasons. However, overnight guests are welcome to explore all common areas throughout their stay.

Photography is permitted throughout the property with respect to other guests’ privacy. Many visitors have captured unexplained anomalies, orbs, and shadow figures in their photographs.

Check-in begins at 3 PM and checkout is at 11 AM daily. The front desk staff is remarkably open about the building’s haunted history and happy to share stories.

Best Time to Visit

Paranormal activity at the Addy Sea occurs year-round with no significant seasonal variations reported. However, the winter months from November through February see fewer guests and potentially more noticeable phenomena.

The hours between midnight and 4 AM produce the most dramatic supernatural encounters according to guest logs. Catherine Addy’s spirit appears most frequently around 2:30 AM specifically in Room 4.

Full moon periods seem to correlate with increased activity levels throughout the building. Multiple witnesses have noted stronger phenomena during the three days surrounding each lunar cycle’s peak.

Weekday stays tend to be quieter than weekends, allowing for more undisturbed paranormal observation. The spirits seem less active when the building is filled with numerous guests and high energy.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

A couple from Pennsylvania reported waking simultaneously at 2:15 AM in Room 4 in October 2019. Both witnessed a woman in white standing motionless at the foot of their bed for approximately one minute.

The apparition appeared completely solid and three-dimensional, not transparent as they expected a ghost would look. She turned to face them directly before dissipating like morning fog in sunshine.

A solo traveler staying in Room 7 documented hearing a child laughing in the hallway in 2020. When he opened the door to investigate, he saw a small shadow dart past and disappear through a solid wall.

Inn staff member Jennifer Martinez shared her experience from a night shift in 2018. She witnessed every door on the second floor open simultaneously at exactly 3:33 AM.

Each door swung open smoothly and silently despite the building’s typically creaky hinges. The doors remained open for approximately five minutes before closing again in perfect synchronization.

A paranormal investigation team from Maryland spent three nights at the property in March 2021. Their equipment captured multiple EVP recordings of a male voice saying “my house” repeatedly.

The same investigation team recorded dramatic temperature fluctuations in the basement area dropping 30 degrees within seconds. Their thermal imaging camera showed a distinctly human-shaped cold mass moving through the space.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

The Atlantic Paranormal Society conducted an informal investigation at the Addy Sea in 2017. While not broadcast as a full episode, team members confirmed significant paranormal activity on their social media.

Local Delaware paranormal investigation groups have studied the property extensively over the past two decades. The Delaware Ghost Hunters documented over forty separate unexplained incidents during their five-year study.

EMF meters consistently show elevated readings in Room 4 and the second-floor hallway with no electrical sources nearby. These electromagnetic field spikes often correlate with visual apparitions and cold spot manifestations.

Spirit box sessions conducted in the basement have yielded intelligent responses to investigators’ questions. The entity below seems to respond with hostility, using aggressive language and threatening phrases.

Photography evidence collected over the years includes hundreds of images showing unexplained light anomalies and shadow figures. One particularly compelling photograph from 2016 clearly shows a Victorian-era man’s reflection in a window with no person present.

Local Legends & Myths

Local Bethany Beach residents whisper about the “Lady in White” who walks the beach near the inn on foggy mornings. Witnesses describe her as searching frantically for something or someone along the waterline.

This beach apparition is believed to be Catherine Addy looking for her grandson who drowned decades ago. She allegedly appears most frequently on the anniversary of the child’s death in August.

Another local legend claims the basement spirit is actually a construction worker who died during the original 1902 building process. No historical documentation confirms this death, but the story persists among longtime residents.

Some locals believe the entire property sits atop an ancient Native American burial ground. Archeological surveys have never been conducted to confirm or deny this persistent regional rumor.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

The Addy Sea is private property operating as a commercial lodging establishment. Only registered guests and their invited visitors may access the building and grounds.

The basement area is strictly off-limits to guests due to safety concerns and liability issues. Staff members discourage even asking about basement access given the area’s structural instability and hostile spiritual presence.

Guests experiencing extreme anxiety or fear should notify the front desk immediately for potential room reassignment. The inn maintains a strict policy of respecting guests who become uncomfortable with paranormal activity.

While no physical harm from supernatural entities has ever been documented at the property, psychological distress is possible. Individuals with heart conditions or severe anxiety disorders should consider carefully before staying in known active rooms.

Nearby Haunted Places

Fort Miles – Haunted Military Fort in Lewes, Delaware

📍 16.2 miles

Cape May – Haunted Historic District in Cape May, New Jersey

📍 28.6 miles

John Dickinson Plantation – Haunted Plantation in Dover, Delaware

📍 44 miles

Woodburn / Governor's Mansion – Haunted Mansion in Dover, Delaware

📍 49.5 miles

Belmont Hall – Haunted Mansion in Smyrna, Delaware

📍 59.4 miles

Point Lookout Lighthouse – Haunted Lighthouse in Scotland, Maryland

📍 77.1 miles