Culbertson Mansion – Haunted Mansion in New Albany, Indiana
Home > Haunted Places > State >
> Culbertson Mansion – Haunted Mansion in New Albany, Indiana
City:
State:
Full Address: 914 E Main St, New Albany, IN 47150
Check In Google Map
Have you visited this place? Rate Your Experience!
The Culbertson Mansion stands as a towering Victorian masterpiece in downtown New Albany, Indiana. This three-story French Second Empire style home has watched over the city since 1867, harboring secrets that go far beyond its ornate architecture.
Visitors and staff members have reported unexplained phenomena throughout the mansion for decades. The ghostly presence of the Culbertson family seems to linger within these walls, unwilling to leave their earthly paradise. The mansion’s reputation as one of Southern Indiana’s most actively haunted locations continues to grow each year.
William S. Culbertson spared no expense when constructing this twenty-five room showplace of wealth and status. Today, the same rooms where the Culbertsons once entertained high society now play host to spectral guests. The mansion has become a focal point for paranormal enthusiasts seeking evidence of life beyond death.
Historical Background
William S. Culbertson commissioned the mansion’s construction in 1867, completing it in 1869. The successful dry goods merchant and banker invested over $120,000 in the property, an astronomical sum at the time. The mansion featured the finest materials money could buy, including hand-painted ceilings and imported marble fireplaces.
The Culbertson family lived in luxury within these walls during New Albany’s golden age. William, his wife Cornelia, and their three children enjoyed every modern convenience available in the late 1800s. The home boasted central heating, gas lighting, and indoor plumbing years before most Americans had such amenities.
Tragedy struck the family multiple times during their residence in the mansion. William Culbertson died unexpectedly in 1892 at the age of 67 while still living in the home. Cornelia continued residing in the mansion until her own death in 1918, spending her final years alone. Their daughter Anna lived in the mansion until she passed away in 1926, the last Culbertson to call it home.
The mansion changed hands several times after the Culbertson family departed. It served as a boarding house for many years before facing possible demolition in the 1960s. Historic New Albany acquired the property in 1976, and the state of Indiana now operates it as a museum.
The building underwent extensive restoration to return it to its 1880s appearance. Workers during the renovation reported numerous unexplained occurrences that couldn’t be dismissed as old house settling. These incidents marked the beginning of documented paranormal activity at the site, sparking interest from ghost hunters statewide.
Paranormal Activity Summary
Cold spots manifest throughout the mansion with no logical explanation for the temperature drops. Visitors frequently report sudden chills in specific rooms, particularly on the second and third floors. These cold areas move and disappear without following any pattern related to heating or ventilation systems.
Phantom footsteps echo through empty hallways when no living person walks those floors. Staff members working alone in the mansion hear distinct footfalls crossing rooms above their heads. Security checks reveal no intruders, yet the sounds continue night after night with unsettling regularity.
Objects move from their designated positions despite the museum’s strict protocols for artifact placement. Tour guides arrive each morning to find items relocated overnight in locked rooms. Small decorative pieces appear in different rooms entirely, as if invisible hands rearrange the mansion’s contents. Doors open and close on their own accord, even when latched and secured properly.
Apparitions appear most frequently in period clothing from the Victorian era. Witnesses describe seeing full-bodied figures that vanish when approached or acknowledged. These ghostly forms appear solid and real until they disappear into thin air or walk through walls.
The scent of lavender perfume wafts through rooms with no flowers or air fresheners present. This distinctive fragrance was popular among Victorian women and suggests a female presence haunting the home. The smell intensifies in certain areas before fading completely, leaving witnesses questioning what they experienced.
By the way, have you visited this haunted place in Indiana State? Hannah House – Haunted Mansion in Indianapolis, Indiana
Ghost Stories & Reports
Cornelia Culbertson remains the most frequently sighted spirit within the mansion’s walls. Her apparition appears wearing elegant Victorian dresses, consistent with her status as the mansion’s mistress. Witnesses describe her as a dignified woman who seems to be inspecting rooms as she did in life.
Cornelia’s ghost allegedly appears most often in the formal parlors on the first floor. She manifests near the ornate furniture she once selected for entertaining prestigious guests. Tour guides have observed a translucent female figure standing beside the gold-trimmed mirrors in the front parlor. The apparition studies her reflection before dissolving like morning mist.
William Culbertson’s spirit reportedly haunts his former study and the library areas. Visitors sense a male presence watching them from the corners of these rooms. Some guests report feeling an invisible hand on their shoulder when examining William’s portrait or personal effects.
The Culbertson children’s spirits allegedly play in the third-floor bedrooms where they once slept. Witnesses hear childish laughter and the sounds of running feet in these upper chambers. Toys and small objects move in the children’s rooms, suggesting playful spirits still occupy their childhood spaces.
One particularly chilling account involves a tour guide who encountered a woman in period dress descending the main staircase. The guide politely asked if the woman needed directions, assuming she was a lost visitor. The figure smiled but continued down the stairs, passing through a locked door at the bottom without opening it.
Night security guards have reported seeing lights moving through rooms after the mansion has closed. These lights appear as candle flames or gas lamp glows moving along the hallways. When guards investigate, they find all modern electric lights switched off and no source for the mysterious illumination.
A former museum director experienced repeated encounters with an unseen presence in the second-floor hallway. She felt someone brush past her numerous times when working alone in the building. The sensation was so real that she would turn expecting to see a colleague, only to find herself completely alone.
Local folklore claims that Cornelia Culbertson refuses to leave her beloved home even in death. She allegedly spent her happiest years in the mansion and couldn’t bear to depart. Residents of New Albany have passed down stories of the ghostly lady in the window for generations.
Planning to Investigate This Location?
Make sure you have the right ghost hunting equipment
View Equipment Guide →Speaking of haunted places, don’t forget to also check this place in Indiana State? Indiana State Sanatorium / Sunnyside Mansion – Haunted Mansion in Madison, Indiana
Most Haunted Spot
The second-floor master bedroom generates the most paranormal reports from visitors and staff members. This room served as Cornelia Culbertson’s private chamber, where she spent countless hours and eventually her final days. Guests standing in this room frequently report feeling watched, followed by sudden temperature drops of 10 to 15 degrees.
The ornate canopy bed in the master bedroom seems to be a focal point for supernatural energy. Visitors have photographed mysterious orbs and light anomalies floating near the bed’s elaborate drapery. Some sensitive individuals refuse to enter the room entirely, claiming the emotional energy feels overwhelming and suffocating.
The servants’ staircase connecting the second and third floors ranks as another highly active paranormal hotspot. This narrow passage served as the staff’s route through the house, keeping them separate from family areas. Footsteps echo constantly on these stairs, and several people have been touched by invisible hands while climbing them.
The paranormal doesn’t stop here—this haunted place might also interest you in Indiana State? 100 Steps Cemetery – Haunted Cemetery in Brazil, Indiana
Can You Visit?
The Culbertson Mansion State Historic Site welcomes visitors year-round for guided tours. The Indiana State Museum and Historic Sites manages the property and offers regular public access. Admission costs $8 for adults, $7 for seniors, and $5 for youth ages 3-17.
Standard guided tours run Tuesday through Saturday from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM. The mansion closes on Sundays, Mondays, and major holidays throughout the year. Tours last approximately 45 minutes and cover all three floors of the historic home.
Special candlelight tours occur during the Halloween season, offering visitors a spookier atmosphere. These evening tours cost slightly more but provide an authentic Victorian experience with period lighting. Photography is permitted throughout the mansion during all tour times, encouraging guests to capture potential paranormal evidence.
The mansion hosts occasional paranormal investigation events for serious ghost hunters. These overnight investigations require advance registration and fill up quickly due to high demand. Participants bring their own equipment and receive exclusive after-hours access to investigate reported haunting hotspots.
Best Time to Visit
Paranormal activity increases significantly during the autumn months, particularly October around Halloween. The mansion’s spirits seem more active when the veil between worlds traditionally grows thinner. Staff members report heightened phenomena during late afternoon hours as natural light fades from the rooms.
Evening candlelight tours provide optimal conditions for potential supernatural encounters and authentic Victorian ambiance. The dim lighting and smaller tour groups create an atmosphere similar to when the Culbertsons actually lived there. Many visitors report their most compelling experiences during these special twilight tours rather than daytime visits.
First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports
A paranormal investigation team from Louisville documented compelling EVP recordings in the mansion during 2015. Their audio equipment captured a female voice saying “my home” in the master bedroom. The team also recorded footsteps and door sounds when all investigators were accounted for in different areas.
Museum staff member Jennifer Matthews reported a particularly unnerving experience while closing the mansion one evening. She heard piano music coming from the music room despite no piano being present. The melody sounded like a Victorian-era composition played on an instrument that had been removed decades earlier.
Tour guide Robert Chen witnessed a full apparition in the formal dining room during 2018. He described seeing a woman in a burgundy Victorian dress examining the table settings. She appeared completely solid until he blinked, at which point she vanished without a trace.
A visitor named Sarah Rodriguez submitted a photograph to the museum showing an unexplained figure in the background. The image, taken during a 2019 tour, shows a translucent form standing in a doorway. No one recalls seeing anyone in that location when the photo was captured.
During renovation work in 2003, construction workers refused to continue working alone in certain areas. Multiple crew members reported tools moving on their own and feeling unseen hands pushing them. The project manager eventually required workers to operate in pairs after several refused to return otherwise.
Paranormal Investigations & Findings
Several regional paranormal investigation teams have studied the Culbertson Mansion extensively over the past two decades. The Southern Indiana Paranormal Society conducted a three-night investigation in 2012 with notable results. Their equipment registered significant electromagnetic field fluctuations in the master bedroom and children’s rooms without any electrical source.
Investigators have captured numerous photographs containing unexplained light anomalies and apparent spirit manifestations. Thermal imaging cameras reveal cold spots that move intelligently through rooms rather than following air currents. These temperature variations can’t be explained by the mansion’s HVAC system or natural environmental factors.
Audio recordings from investigations consistently produce EVP phenomena throughout the mansion’s three floors. Disembodied voices respond to investigator questions in period-appropriate language and accents. One remarkable recording captured a voice identifying itself as “Cornelia” when asked who was present in the room.
Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions
The Culbertson Mansion operates as a state historic site with strict visitation rules and regulations. Trespassing outside of official tour hours constitutes a criminal offense prosecuted by local authorities. The New Albany Police Department regularly patrols the property and will arrest unauthorized visitors attempting after-hours access.
Visitors must stay with tour groups and follow guide instructions for both safety and preservation reasons. The mansion contains priceless antiques and irreplaceable historical artifacts that require careful protection. Touching exhibits or wandering away from groups may result in removal from the property without refund.
Cursed or Haunted Objects
An ornate Victorian mirror in the master bedroom has generated numerous reports of paranormal phenomena. Visitors claim to see faces other than their own reflections appearing in the silvered glass. Some photographs taken of this mirror show shadowy figures standing behind the photographer despite no one being there.
Cornelia Culbertson’s jewelry box remains on display in her former bedroom chamber. Staff members report the box opens on its own despite being secured closed each night. The delicate music mechanism inside occasionally plays without anyone winding it, filling the room with ghostly melodies. Guards have heard the tinkling music box during late night rounds when the mansion stands completely empty.
Book Ghost Tours & Haunted Experiences
Explore paranormal adventures with expert guides. Secure booking through Viator.
Nearby Haunted Places
Visitor Reports (0)
No experiences shared yet. Be the first!
Community Experiences
Share your paranormal encounters, photos, and rate this location
Login to Share Your Experience
Sign in to upload photos, write comments, and rate this location