Stepp Cemetery – Haunted Cemetery in Bloomington, Indiana

Deep in the woods of southern Indiana lies a small abandoned cemetery that whispers tales of sorrow. Stepp Cemetery sits isolated on a hilltop, surrounded by dense forest and an eerie silence. The graveyard dates back to the mid-1800s and contains fewer than two dozen visible graves. Most visitors come seeking the ghost of a grieving mother who lost her child.

Local legend calls this one of Indiana’s most haunted locations. The cemetery draws paranormal investigators and curious thrill-seekers from across the Midwest. Stories of phantom crying, mysterious lights, and an angry guardian spirit have circulated for decades. Even skeptics admit the place carries an unsettling atmosphere that penetrates to the bone.

The cemetery sits on what was once the Stepp family farmland in Morgan-Monroe State Forest. A narrow dirt road leads to the isolated burial ground through towering trees. The journey itself feels like stepping back in time to a forgotten era. Many who make the trek report feeling watched long before reaching the cemetery gates.

Historical Background

The Stepp family established their cemetery around 1850 when they first settled the area. George and Minerva Stepp purchased the land and began farming the rugged Indiana terrain. The family used a small plot on their property as a private burial ground. This practice was common among rural farming families during that era in southern Indiana.

The cemetery’s most notable grave belongs to an infant who died in the 1850s. Records indicate the child was the daughter of a family connected to the Stepps. The exact cause of death remains unclear due to incomplete historical records. Infant mortality rates were tragically high during this period in American history.

The Stepp family eventually abandoned their farm in the late 1800s. They left behind their small cemetery on the hilltop when they departed. The property gradually returned to wilderness as the forest reclaimed the cleared farmland. Only the cemetery remained as evidence of the family’s presence in these woods.

The State of Indiana acquired the land in the 1920s for forest preservation. Officials incorporated the area into what became Morgan-Monroe State Forest. The cemetery was left undisturbed as a protected historical site. Weathered headstones still mark graves despite more than a century of exposure to elements.

Several gravestones bear names from prominent local families of the 1850s and 1860s. The McGuire family has multiple burials in the small plot of land. Other stones have become too worn to read after years of harsh Indiana winters. Some graves likely exist without any remaining markers to identify the deceased.

Paranormal Activity Summary

Visitors to Stepp Cemetery consistently report hearing the sound of a woman crying. The phantom weeping seems to emanate from near the infant’s grave at the cemetery’s center. Many describe the crying as heartbreaking and filled with profound grief. The sounds intensify as people approach the small child’s weathered headstone.

Strange lights have been witnessed floating among the tombstones after dark. These orbs appear as glowing spheres that drift between graves without any logical source. Witnesses describe them as yellowish-white in color and roughly basketball-sized. The lights reportedly respond to human presence by moving away or disappearing entirely.

Visitors frequently experience sudden temperature drops in specific areas of the cemetery. Cold spots manifest even during warm summer evenings without any natural explanation. These chilling zones often occur near the infant’s grave where the crying sounds originate. Some people report feeling unseen hands touching them within these cold areas.

Electronic devices malfunction with alarming frequency within the cemetery’s boundaries. Cameras drain batteries within minutes despite being fully charged moments before. Cell phones lose signal completely even in areas that normally have coverage. Voice recorders capture unexplained sounds and voices not heard during the actual visit.

An overwhelming sense of sadness washes over many people who enter the grounds. This emotional heaviness feels external rather than from within the visitor’s own feelings. Some describe it as absorbing someone else’s grief and despair. The sensation grows stronger near the center of the cemetery where the oldest graves rest.

Ghost Stories & Reports

The primary ghost haunting Stepp Cemetery is known as the Lady in Black. Legend identifies her as the mother of the infant buried in the cemetery. She supposedly died of grief shortly after losing her child to illness. Her spirit remains tethered to this lonely hilltop, eternally mourning her lost baby.

Witnesses describe seeing a woman in a long black Victorian mourning dress. She appears near the infant’s grave, standing motionless or kneeling at the small headstone. Her face remains hidden behind a dark veil that obscures her features completely. She vanishes without warning when observers attempt to approach or speak to her.

The Lady in Black reportedly becomes aggressive toward anyone who disrespects the cemetery. Teenagers who have vandalized headstones or partied among the graves report being chased. The spirit transforms from a sorrowful mourner into a protective guardian of the dead. Visitors who show reverence and respect reportedly experience only sadness rather than anger.

One popular legend tells of three young men who urinated on graves in 1996. According to the story, all three died in separate accidents within six months. Local residents claim the Lady in Black cursed them for their desecration of sacred ground. Whether this tale is fact or fiction remains debated among Bloomington locals.

A phantom baby’s cry sometimes accompanies the woman’s weeping according to multiple reports. The infant’s wails sound distressed and seem to call out for its mother. This dual haunting of mother and child creates an intensely emotional paranormal experience. Many visitors find themselves crying along with the spirits without understanding why.

Some witnesses report seeing a tall shadowy figure standing at the cemetery’s edge. This entity appears separate from the Lady in Black and exhibits different behavior. The shadow man watches visitors but does not approach or interact with them. Theories suggest this could be Mr. Stepp himself guarding his family’s burial plot.

Disembodied footsteps crunch through leaves when no visible person walks the grounds. The sounds circle around visitors as if someone is patrolling the perimeter. These phantom footfalls stop abruptly when people turn to look in their direction. The invisible presence resumes walking once the observer looks away again.

Most Haunted Spot

The small infant’s grave at the cemetery’s center generates the most paranormal activity. This weathered headstone marks the resting place of a child who died in 1852. The Lady in Black appears most frequently at this precise location within the grounds. Visitors standing near this grave report the strongest emotional and physical sensations.

A large tree stands directly behind the infant’s grave marker at the plot’s center. This gnarled oak has twisted branches that create unsettling shadows across the headstones. Many photographs taken near this tree show mysterious orbs and strange light anomalies. The combination of the infant’s grave and ancient tree creates the cemetery’s most active zone.

The wrought iron gate at the cemetery’s entrance also experiences significant paranormal phenomena. The gate reportedly swings open and closed by itself with no wind present. Visitors have photographed the gate and captured shadowy figures standing near the entrance. Some people feel physically prevented from entering as if an invisible barrier blocks them.

Can You Visit?

Stepp Cemetery is technically accessible to the public as it sits within state forest land. However, Monroe County officials strongly discourage visitation due to trespassing and vandalism concerns. The cemetery is not maintained as an official tourist destination or historic site. Visitors who choose to go do so at their own risk legally and physically.

There is no entry fee to visit the cemetery or Morgan-Monroe State Forest. The forest itself offers legitimate hiking trails and recreational opportunities during daylight hours. Stepp Cemetery Road is a narrow dirt path that requires careful navigation. Many visitors park near the forest edge and hike approximately one mile to reach the cemetery.

No official tours operate at this location due to its isolated nature. Paranormal investigation groups occasionally organize unofficial nighttime visits with proper permissions. Photography is generally allowed but must be done respectfully without disturbing grave markers. Flash photography may be prohibited depending on current local regulations regarding cemetery photography.

Visiting hours are not formally established since the cemetery is abandoned property. Most paranormal activity reportedly occurs between midnight and 3 AM during new moon phases. Daytime visits are safer but yield fewer supernatural encounters according to investigators. Local law enforcement does patrol the area and may question visitors about their intentions.

Best Time to Visit

Paranormal activity peaks during autumn months from September through November according to regular visitors. The anniversary of the infant’s death in late October supposedly triggers increased manifestations. Cold October nights seem to draw out the Lady in Black more frequently. The fall season aligns with traditional beliefs about the veil between worlds thinning.

Nighttime visits between midnight and 3 AM produce the most consistent supernatural encounters. This timeframe is considered the “witching hour” when spiritual energy concentrates most powerfully. The Lady in Black appears almost exclusively after dark when shadows deepen among tombstones. Brave investigators recommend arriving around 11 PM and staying through the peak activity window.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

Indiana University student Jennifer Morrison visited Stepp Cemetery in October 2015 with three friends. She reported hearing distinct crying sounds that made her feel overwhelming sadness. Jennifer’s camera captured a misty white figure near the infant’s grave in multiple photographs. Her entire group felt cold spots despite the evening temperature being relatively mild.

Paranormal investigator Robert Chen documented his 2018 visit in a detailed online report. His EMF meter showed extreme fluctuations near the center of the cemetery grounds. Robert’s digital voice recorder captured a woman’s voice saying “my baby” clearly. He described feeling unwelcome and watched throughout his entire two-hour investigation.

Local Bloomington resident Thomas Hayes grew up hearing stories about the haunted cemetery. He visited in 1989 as a teenager on a dare from friends. Thomas claims he saw a woman in dark clothing standing motionless among the graves. When he called out to her, she turned and he saw empty blackness where her face should be.

A paranormal research team from Indianapolis investigated the site in March 2020. Lead investigator Sarah Martinez reported multiple personal experiences during their overnight stay. The team captured thermal imaging that showed a human-shaped cold spot near the infant’s grave. Their findings were published in the Indiana Paranormal Research Journal that summer.

Amateur ghost hunter David Kowalski maintains a blog documenting his multiple visits since 2012. He has photographed the cemetery in all seasons and various weather conditions. David claims his most dramatic encounter occurred during a thunderstorm in June 2016. He witnessed what appeared to be a woman’s figure illuminated by lightning near the entrance gate.

Local Legends & Myths

One persistent legend claims that walking around the infant’s grave three times at midnight summons the Lady in Black. Witnesses who have attempted this ritual report seeing a black mist forming near the headstone. The mist supposedly coalesces into the shape of a woman in mourning clothes. This urban legend has drawn countless teenagers to the cemetery over the decades.

Another myth suggests leaving toys or flowers at the baby’s grave appeases the grieving mother’s spirit. Visitors who bring gifts reportedly experience peaceful encounters rather than frightening manifestations. The Lady in Black appears grateful and calm when offerings are left with respect. However, taking anything from the cemetery supposedly invokes her wrath and a terrible curse.

Local folklore warns that photographing the infant’s grave brings bad luck to the photographer. Several people claim their cameras were permanently damaged after taking pictures at this spot. Others report experiencing a string of misfortunes in the weeks following their cemetery visit. These stories have not deterred paranormal investigators who continue documenting the site extensively.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

The Ghost Research Society of Indiana conducted multiple investigations at Stepp Cemetery between 2010 and 2015. Their team recorded several EVP sessions with compelling results captured on audio equipment. One recording allegedly contains a woman’s voice saying “leave us alone” quite clearly. The society’s findings were published in their annual report on Indiana’s most haunted locations.

A regional paranormal television series featured Stepp Cemetery in a 2017 Halloween special episode. The investigation team reported experiencing equipment malfunctions and unexplained temperature fluctuations throughout filming. Thermal cameras captured anomalies that defied natural explanation near the infant’s grave marker. The episode generated renewed interest in the cemetery among ghost hunting enthusiasts.

Independent researcher Dr. Patricia Wells conducted a historical and paranormal study in 2019. She combined archival research with overnight investigations using scientific methodology and controls. Dr. Wells documented consistent cold spots in three specific locations within the cemetery boundaries. Her peer-reviewed paper stopped short of confirming supernatural activity but acknowledged unexplained phenomena.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

Monroe County authorities have posted no trespassing signs near the cemetery entrance. Visitors can face citations or arrest for being on the property without permission. The narrow dirt road leading to the cemetery becomes treacherous during rain or winter weather. Several vehicles have become stuck requiring expensive towing from the remote forest location.

The cemetery sits in a heavily wooded area with significant wildlife including deer, coyotes, and occasional black bears. Visitors walking to the site at night face genuine physical dangers beyond supernatural concerns. Copperhead snakes are common in southern Indiana and pose a real threat during warmer months. Cell phone service is unreliable in this remote area, making emergency calls difficult.

Old cemetery infrastructure including iron fencing and damaged headstones present injury hazards. The ground is uneven with hidden holes and exposed tree roots throughout. Visitors have twisted ankles and suffered falls resulting in serious injuries. The isolation means help is far away should an accident occur on the property.

Local law enforcement increased patrols after vandalism incidents damaged historic gravestones in 2016. Officers may question anyone found at the cemetery, especially after dark. Trespassing charges can result in fines up to $500 and potential jail time. Authorities ask that people respect the dead and avoid disturbing this historic burial ground.

Nearby Haunted Places

The Story Inn – Haunted Hotel in Story, Indiana

📍 18.8 miles

Avon Haunted Bridge – Haunted Bridge in Avon, Indiana

📍 30.7 miles

Hannah House – Haunted Mansion in Indianapolis, Indiana

📍 31.4 miles

Central State Hospital – Haunted Asylum in Indianapolis, Indiana

📍 33.5 miles

James Whitcomb Riley House – Haunted Museum in Indianapolis, Indiana

📍 35.1 miles

100 Steps Cemetery – Haunted Cemetery in Brazil, Indiana

📍 44.8 miles