Pine Hill Cemetery – Haunted Cemetery in Hollis, New Hampshire

Nestled among the rolling hills of southern New Hampshire sits a burial ground with secrets. Pine Hill Cemetery has watched over the town of Hollis since the late 1700s. The weathered headstones stand silent witness to centuries of deaths both peaceful and tragic. Visitors report strange feelings of being watched among the graves.

This historic cemetery spans several acres of consecrated ground. Ancient maple trees cast long shadows across the tombstones throughout the day. Local residents have shared tales of ghostly encounters here for generations. The cemetery’s reputation as one of New Hampshire’s most haunted locations continues to grow.

Many paranormal investigators have documented unusual activity within these cemetery gates. Strange lights appear between the graves on moonless nights. Unexplained voices echo through the tombstones when no living person is present. The spirits here seem restless and eager to make contact with the living.

Historical Background

Pine Hill Cemetery was established in 1762 to serve the growing Hollis community. The first recorded burial took place on November 3, 1762. Early settlers chose this elevated location for its peaceful views and well-drained soil. The cemetery quickly became the final resting place for prominent colonial families.

The burial ground expanded significantly during the Revolutionary War era. Several soldiers who fought for American independence now rest beneath these grounds. Their graves are marked with weathered stones bearing patriotic symbols and military honors. The cemetery received its official charter from the town of Hollis in 1789.

Tragedy struck the cemetery grounds multiple times throughout the 19th century. A devastating cholera outbreak in 1832 resulted in mass burials within a single week. Entire families were interred together as the epidemic ravaged the small town. The victims’ graves form a distinct cluster in the cemetery’s northeastern section.

The Civil War brought more sorrow to Pine Hill Cemetery between 1861 and 1865. Twenty-three local men who died in battle were eventually brought home for burial. Their bodies arrived in various states of preservation after long journeys from distant battlefields. Some families never recovered the remains of their loved ones at all.

A mysterious fire destroyed the cemetery’s original record house in 1897. Many burial records dating back to the cemetery’s founding were lost forever. This tragedy has made identifying some of the older graves nearly impossible. Historians believe dozens of unmarked graves exist throughout the property.

Paranormal Activity Summary

Visitors to Pine Hill Cemetery consistently report experiencing sudden temperature drops without explanation. These cold spots appear even during warm summer afternoons in direct sunlight. The temperature can plummet by twenty degrees within just a few feet. Many witnesses describe feeling an icy breath against their necks near certain graves.

Shadow figures are among the most commonly reported phenomena at the cemetery. Multiple witnesses have seen dark human shapes moving between the tombstones at dusk. These shadows appear to walk with purpose along the cemetery’s winding paths. They vanish completely when approached or when direct light falls upon them.

Electronic devices frequently malfunction within the cemetery grounds without any logical cause. Camera batteries drain from full charge to empty in mere minutes. Cell phones shut down spontaneously despite having adequate power moments before. Audio recording equipment captures strange voices and sounds that weren’t audible during recording.

Many visitors report hearing their names called out by disembodied voices. The voices sound different to each witness but always seem urgent and insistent. Some people describe hearing whispered conversations in what sounds like colonial-era English. Others report hearing crying or moaning sounds coming from empty sections of the cemetery.

Physical sensations of being touched are frequently reported throughout Pine Hill Cemetery. Witnesses describe feeling invisible hands grabbing their arms or shoulders from behind. Some visitors report their clothing being tugged as if someone wants their attention. These physical encounters leave people feeling deeply unsettled and eager to leave the grounds.

Ghost Stories & Reports

The most famous spirit haunting Pine Hill Cemetery is known locally as the Blue Lady. Witnesses describe seeing a woman in a flowing blue colonial dress near the cholera victims’ section. She appears most frequently on foggy autumn evenings just after sunset. Her face reportedly shows signs of the disease that likely claimed her life.

The Blue Lady seems to be searching for something among the graves. She moves methodically from stone to stone as if reading each inscription carefully. Some witnesses report she appears to be crying or calling out names. When approached, she fades away like morning mist touched by sunlight.

Local historian Margaret Foster documented an encounter with the Blue Lady in 1983. She was conducting evening research on colonial burial practices when the apparition appeared. Foster described feeling an overwhelming sadness wash over her during the sighting. The ghost allegedly made eye contact before vanishing completely.

Another well-documented spirit is that of Captain Abel Stone, buried here in 1779. Stone was a Revolutionary War officer who died under mysterious circumstances after the war. His ghost appears in full military uniform near his prominent headstone. Witnesses describe him as looking solid and real until he suddenly disappears.

Captain Stone’s spirit seems to be standing guard over a specific section of graves. He appears to patrol the same route repeatedly throughout the night hours. Several paranormal investigators have captured photographs showing a uniformed figure near his monument. The figure never appears in consecutive shots despite the camera remaining stationary.

The ghost of a young girl named Abigail Prescott haunts the cemetery’s western edge. Abigail died in 1844 at just seven years old from scarlet fever. Her spirit appears as a child in a white nightgown carrying a rag doll. Witnesses report she seems confused and calls out for her mother.

Multiple families visiting the cemetery have reported encounters with Abigail’s ghost. She allegedly approaches living children and tries to play with them. Parents describe their children speaking to someone invisible before pointing out the ghostly girl. The apparition reportedly smiles sadly before fading away when adults acknowledge her presence.

A Revolutionary War drummer boy also haunts the older section of Pine Hill Cemetery. His spirit appears near the soldiers’ graves playing an invisible drum. Witnesses report hearing the distinct sound of military drumming echoing through the cemetery. The phantom drummer appears to be leading an invisible regiment through the graves.

This drummer boy ghost is believed to be Thomas Wheeler, who died at age fourteen in 1778. Wheeler served with Captain Stone’s company before dying of pneumonia. His small grave marker sits among the Revolutionary War veterans’ section. Local legend claims he’s still performing his military duties despite being dead for over two centuries.

Most Haunted Spot

The most intensely haunted location within Pine Hill Cemetery is undoubtedly the cholera victims’ section. This cluster of graves in the northeastern corner experiences constant paranormal activity. The Blue Lady appears here most frequently along with numerous other shadowy figures. Visitors report feeling physically ill when standing among these particular graves.

The temperature in this section remains noticeably colder than surrounding areas year-round. Multiple thermometer readings have documented temperature differences of up to fifteen degrees. Feelings of overwhelming sadness and despair wash over people who linger here. Some visitors report feeling unable to breathe properly as if experiencing disease symptoms themselves.

EVP recordings captured in the cholera section contain dozens of distinct voices. These recordings include coughing, crying, and pleading in desperate tones. One particularly chilling recording allegedly captures a woman’s voice saying “help us, we’re still here.” Paranormal investigators consider this section one of New Hampshire’s most active haunted locations.

Can You Visit?

Pine Hill Cemetery is open to the public for respectful visitation during daylight hours. The cemetery gates are accessible from dawn until dusk every day of the year. Entry to the cemetery grounds is completely free for all visitors. The town of Hollis maintains the property and asks visitors to respect the graves.

Official guided tours are not regularly scheduled at Pine Hill Cemetery. However, the Hollis Historical Society occasionally organizes special heritage walks during October. These tours focus on the cemetery’s history rather than paranormal activity specifically. Advance registration through the historical society is required for these special events.

Photography is permitted throughout the cemetery for personal and research purposes. Many paranormal investigators have captured compelling evidence using various photographic techniques. Visitors are asked to be respectful when photographing graves and monuments. Flash photography is discouraged to preserve the weathered headstones from additional damage.

The cemetery officially closes at dusk and overnight visits are not permitted. The Hollis Police Department regularly patrols the area after dark. Trespassing after hours can result in citations and potential criminal charges. Anyone caught on the property after closing faces fines up to five hundred dollars.

Best Time to Visit

The most significant paranormal activity at Pine Hill Cemetery occurs during autumn months. September through November produces the highest number of documented ghostly encounters. The Blue Lady appears most frequently during this season according to historical records. Cool, foggy evenings seem to increase the likelihood of supernatural experiences.

Within the permitted visiting hours, late afternoon approaching dusk shows increased activity. The hour before sunset between 5 and 6 PM produces numerous shadow figure sightings. This transitional time between day and night seems to create optimal conditions. Many paranormal researchers call this period the “witching hour” despite the common midnight association.

Anniversary dates of historical tragedies also show heightened paranormal phenomena. November 3rd marks the first burial and sees increased spiritual energy annually. The week surrounding this date produces multiple witness reports each year. Similarly, dates in July corresponding to cholera epidemic deaths show unusual activity patterns.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

Jennifer Walsh, a Hollis resident, reported a terrifying encounter in October 2015. She was visiting her grandmother’s grave one overcast afternoon around 4 PM. Walsh described seeing a woman in old-fashioned blue clothing standing motionless among nearby graves. When Walsh called out a greeting, the figure turned and revealed a face marked by visible sores.

Walsh stated the woman’s eyes appeared hollow and filled with immeasurable sadness. The figure raised one hand as if reaching toward Walsh before completely vanishing. Walsh fled the cemetery and reported feeling physically cold for hours afterward. Her photograph from moments before the encounter shows nothing unusual in the area.

Michael Brennan, a genealogy researcher from Massachusetts, documented unusual activity in 2018. Brennan was photographing Revolutionary War graves for a historical database project. His digital camera captured a clearly visible uniformed figure standing beside Captain Stone’s monument. Brennan insists he was completely alone in that section when the photo was taken.

The photograph shows a man in 18th-century military dress with visible facial features. Brennan reported feeling watched throughout his visit but saw nothing with his naked eye. When he returned to the same spot thirty seconds later for another photo, the figure had vanished. Photography experts have examined the image and found no evidence of digital manipulation.

The Hollis Police Department responded to a disturbance call at the cemetery in July 2019. A couple reported hearing screaming and crying coming from inside the locked cemetery after dark. Officers investigated thoroughly but found no living people present within the grounds. The couple insisted the sounds were clearly audible from outside the fence.

Officer David Martinez filed a report noting the couple appeared genuinely frightened and sober. Martinez stated in his report that he heard no unusual sounds during his investigation. However, his body camera footage allegedly captured faint voices that weren’t noticed during the initial incident. The recording has been reviewed by paranormal researchers who confirmed multiple distinct voices.

Rebecca Chen, a paranormal investigator from Boston, led a team investigation in October 2020. Her group spent four hours in the cemetery conducting various scientific measurements. Chen’s team recorded over thirty distinct EVP samples throughout the evening. Multiple shadow figures were observed moving through the cholera victims’ section.

Chen reported experiencing physical contact when an invisible force grabbed her arm. The incident left visible red marks on her forearm that resembled finger impressions. Her team’s thermal imaging camera captured a human-shaped cold spot moving independently among graves. Chen considers Pine Hill Cemetery one of the most convincingly haunted locations she’s investigated.

Local Legends & Myths

A persistent local legend claims that counting the graves will summon the Blue Lady. According to this tale, anyone who attempts to count every headstone will hear a woman crying. The legend states that the counter will lose track repeatedly due to supernatural interference. Upon reaching the cholera section, the Blue Lady allegedly appears to complete the count herself.

Another popular legend involves whistling while walking through the cemetery after 5 PM. Local folklore claims that whistling will anger the spirits and invite them to follow you home. Several families in Hollis have stories about relatives who whistled in the cemetery. These individuals allegedly experienced poltergeist activity in their homes for weeks afterward.

An old superstition warns against photographing Captain Stone’s monument after sunset. The legend claims that anyone who captures his image on film will experience military-themed nightmares. Some versions of the tale suggest the photographer will be cursed with bad luck. Despite the cemetery being closed after dark, this legend persists in local folklore.

One particularly dark legend involves the unmarked graves from the 1897 fire. Local storytellers claim that the spirits in these forgotten graves are the most angry. They allegedly resent being forgotten and having their resting places lost to history. Some versions suggest these nameless spirits are responsible for the most aggressive paranormal encounters.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

The Atlantic Paranormal Society conducted a formal investigation at Pine Hill Cemetery in September 2016. The team spent two nights collecting data using advanced electromagnetic field detection equipment. They documented numerous EMF spikes that correlated with temperature anomalies and personal experiences. Their investigation revealed consistent patterns suggesting genuine paranormal activity rather than random environmental factors.

TAPS investigators captured several compelling EVP recordings during their investigation. One recording clearly contains a male voice saying “not forgotten” near the soldiers’ graves. Another recording from the cholera section includes multiple overlapping voices speaking simultaneously. The team’s final report classified Pine Hill Cemetery as legitimately haunted based on their evidence.

The New England Ghost Project featured Pine Hill Cemetery in their 2018 documentary series. Lead investigator Sarah Morrison described the location as extraordinarily active during their three-night investigation. The team captured full-bodied shadow figures on multiple infrared cameras simultaneously. Their investigation documented the most EVP recordings they had collected from any single location.

Morrison’s team experienced numerous equipment failures throughout their investigation despite using backup systems. All three of their digital recorders failed within minutes of each other in the cholera section. Battery packs that were fully charged and tested drained completely within fifteen minutes. These technical failures occurred repeatedly in specific areas of the cemetery.

A 2021 investigation by the Boston University Paranormal Research Club produced startling results. Student researchers used scientific protocols to document environmental conditions throughout an entire weekend. They recorded temperature variations that defied natural explanation in multiple locations. Their research paper concluded that Pine Hill Cemetery exhibits anomalous environmental patterns consistent with reported hauntings.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

Visitors must understand that trespassing after posted hours is strictly prohibited at Pine Hill Cemetery. The Hollis Police Department takes cemetery violations seriously and prosecutes trespassers. Violators face substantial fines and possible criminal records for unauthorized access after dusk. The cemetery’s isolation makes it difficult to claim ignorance of posted closing times.

The cemetery grounds contain numerous tripping hazards including sunken graves and uneven terrain. Visitors should watch their footing carefully while walking between headstones and monuments. Twisted ankles and falls are common accidents even during daylight hours. Proper footwear is essential for safely navigating the cemetery’s historic grounds.

Many of the older headstones are fragile and can be damaged by careless contact. Visitors should never touch, lean on, or climb on any grave markers or monuments. These historic artifacts are irreplaceable pieces of American heritage requiring careful preservation. The town can hold visitors financially liable for any damage to cemetery property.

Cell phone service is unreliable throughout much of Pine Hill Cemetery due to its location. Visitors should inform someone of their plans before visiting the isolated cemetery. Emergency services may be delayed in reaching the cemetery if needed. Visiting alone is strongly discouraged for both safety and legal liability reasons.

Nearby Haunted Places

Gilson Road Cemetery – Haunted Cemetery in Nashua, New Hampshire

📍 3.8 miles

Mystery Hill / America's Stonehenge – Haunted Archaeological Site in Salem, New Hampshire

📍 17.6 miles

Peterborough Town House – Haunted Historic Inn in Peterborough, New Hampshire

📍 22.2 miles

Concord's Colonial Inn – Haunted Hotel in Concord, Massachusetts

📍 23.3 miles

S.K. Pierce Mansion – Haunted Victorian Mansion in Gardner, Massachusetts

📍 26.8 miles

Longfellow's Wayside Inn – Haunted Historic Inn in Sudbury, Massachusetts

📍 28.6 miles