Constantine Theater – Haunted Theater in Pawhuska, Oklahoma

The Constantine Theater stands as a grand testament to small-town America’s golden age of entertainment. This majestic building has welcomed audiences since 1914, offering everything from vaudeville acts to modern cinema.

But the Constantine Theater holds more than just memories of performances past. Visitors and staff report unexplained phenomena that suggest the building’s former patrons never truly left.

Located in the heart of Pawhuska’s historic downtown district, this theater has become legendary among paranormal enthusiasts. The building’s ornate architecture and rich history create the perfect backdrop for ghostly encounters.

Multiple witnesses have documented strange occurrences within these walls over the decades. From phantom footsteps echoing through empty hallways to unexplained cold spots in the auditorium, something supernatural lingers here.

The theater continues to operate today, blending its haunted reputation with ongoing entertainment programming. Staff members have grown accustomed to the building’s otherworldly residents, though visitors often leave shaken by their experiences.

Historical Background

Constantine H. Daniels commissioned the theater’s construction in 1914, naming it after himself. The building cost approximately $40,000 to construct, an astronomical sum for that era in rural Oklahoma.

Pawhuska was thriving during the early twentieth century thanks to the Osage Nation’s oil wealth. The town needed a grand entertainment venue to match its newfound prosperity and cultural aspirations.

The Constantine opened its doors on March 15, 1914, with a spectacular vaudeville performance. Over 500 people packed the auditorium that night, marveling at the theater’s electric lighting and modern amenities.

Throughout the 1920s and 1930s, the venue hosted traveling shows, local theater productions, and motion pictures. Silent films accompanied by live piano music drew crowds from surrounding counties every weekend.

The theater survived the Great Depression, though barely, becoming a crucial community gathering space during difficult times. When World War II arrived, the Constantine hosted war bond rallies and provided escape through entertainment.

By the 1960s, the building had fallen into disrepair as newer entertainment options emerged. The Constantine closed its doors in 1987, sitting vacant and deteriorating for over two decades.

A restoration project began in 2013, breathing new life into the historic structure. Workers reported numerous strange experiences during renovation, sparking renewed interest in the theater’s haunted reputation.

The Constantine Theater reopened in 2017, once again serving the Pawhuska community. Today it functions as both a performance venue and a reminder of Oklahoma’s cultural heritage.

Paranormal Activity Summary

Shadow figures appear most frequently in the upper balcony section during evening hours. These dark forms move independently, often crossing directly in front of startled audience members.

Disembodied footsteps echo through the building when no living person walks the halls. Staff members report hearing these phantom sounds almost daily, particularly near the original dressing rooms.

The theater’s original chandeliers swing without any apparent cause or air movement. This phenomenon occurs most often during quiet afternoon hours when the building stands otherwise empty.

Cold spots manifest suddenly in specific locations throughout the auditorium and backstage areas. Witnesses describe these temperature drops as intense, lowering ambient temperature by twenty degrees or more.

Unexplained voices whisper from empty rooms, sometimes forming coherent words or phrases. Several staff members have recorded these sounds on their mobile phones, capturing eerie audio evidence.

The theater’s original pipe organ occasionally produces single notes without being touched. This instrument, installed during the 1914 opening, seems to retain some ghostly connection to past musicians.

Doors lock and unlock themselves throughout the building, frustrating maintenance staff and security personnel. The theater’s manager has replaced locks multiple times, yet the phenomenon continues unabated.

Audience members sometimes report feeling invisible hands touch their shoulders or brush against their arms. These physical encounters happen most frequently in seats E7 through E12 on the main floor.

Ghost Stories & Reports

The most famous spirit haunting the Constantine is believed to be Constantine Daniels himself. Workers during the 2013 renovation repeatedly encountered a well-dressed elderly gentleman inspecting their work.

This figure would appear in period-appropriate clothing from the 1920s, complete with suspenders and a pocket watch. When workers approached to speak with him, he would simply vanish before their eyes.

One construction supervisor named Michael Torres documented three separate encounters with this apparition. He described feeling an overwhelming sense of being watched and judged, as though the spirit disapproved of modern changes.

Another prominent ghost is known simply as “The Actress” by theater staff members. Witnesses describe her as a young woman in a 1930s-era evening gown, always carrying a single red rose.

She appears most frequently in the backstage area near the original dressing rooms. Staff members have reported seeing her reflection in mirrors when no physical person stands behind them.

Local legend claims this woman was an aspiring performer named Eleanor Whitmore who died in 1937. She allegedly fell from the catwalk above the stage during a rehearsal, breaking her neck instantly.

Theater employees have reported finding single red rose petals scattered across the stage with no explanation. Fresh petals appear even in winter when no roses bloom anywhere in the region.

A child’s laughter echoes through the building, though no children are present when staff investigate. This ghostly giggling seems to emanate from the upper balcony, moving from seat to seat.

Some witnesses believe this is the spirit of Tommy Patterson, a seven-year-old who died of influenza in 1918. His parents were theater regulars who brought him to Saturday matinee performances before his tragic death.

The projection booth houses another restless spirit, believed to be former projectionist Harold “Hal” Morrison. Hal worked at the Constantine from 1952 until his fatal heart attack in 1973.

He collapsed while threading film through the projector, dying alone in his small booth. Current projectionists report equipment turning on and off without explanation, as though Hal continues his duties.

One projectionist named Sarah Chen reported seeing a transparent figure operating the old 35mm projector in 2018. The figure gestured for her to leave, and she felt an overwhelming urge to exit immediately.

Most Haunted Spot

The balcony’s back three rows represent the Constantine Theater’s most intensely haunted area. Visitors sitting in these seats report overwhelming feelings of dread and being watched by unseen entities.

Seat B-14 in particular seems to serve as a focal point for paranormal activity. Multiple witnesses have photographed strange orbs and mists appearing directly above this specific location.

The temperature in this section drops dramatically even when the building’s heating system functions perfectly. Staff members have measured temperature differences exceeding fifteen degrees compared to surrounding areas.

Shadow figures appear most frequently along the balcony’s center aisle, moving from back to front. These entities sometimes lean over the railing as though watching performances on the stage below.

One paranormal investigation team recorded electronic voice phenomena in this area during a 2019 overnight study. Their recordings captured a male voice saying “Get out” and “My seat” repeatedly.

Can You Visit?

The Constantine Theater is open to the public and actively welcomes visitors throughout the year. The venue hosts regular theatrical performances, concerts, and special events that provide access to the historic building.

Admission prices vary depending on the specific event or performance being attended. Movie screenings typically cost between $8 and $12, while live performances range from $15 to $40.

The theater offers special paranormal investigation tours on select Friday and Saturday evenings by reservation. These guided ghost hunts cost $45 per person and include access to normally restricted areas.

Photography is permitted throughout the building during tours and most public events. Flash photography may be restricted during live performances to avoid disturbing other audience members.

Regular operating hours are Thursday through Sunday from 2 PM until 11 PM. The theater occasionally opens for special weekday events, which are announced on their official website and social media.

Best Time to Visit

Paranormal activity intensifies dramatically during late evening hours between 10 PM and 2 AM. Staff closing the building after performances report the highest frequency of unexplained phenomena during this timeframe.

October through December represents the peak season for supernatural encounters at the Constantine Theater. The theater staff theorizes that increased visitor energy during fall performances somehow amplifies spiritual activity.

Full moon periods seem to correlate with heightened ghostly manifestations, though no scientific explanation exists. Multiple witnesses have independently reported more intense experiences during these lunar phases over the years.

Tuesday and Wednesday nights, when the building stands completely empty, also produce remarkable paranormal evidence. Security camera footage from these quiet periods has captured numerous unexplained anomalies and shadow movements.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

Theater manager Rebecca Martinez shared her most terrifying experience during a 2020 local news interview. She was alone in the building after midnight when she heard full orchestral music emanating from the sealed orchestra pit.

Martinez investigated the sound and found the pit completely empty, yet the music continued playing. She described hearing a full band performing a waltz from the 1920s before the music abruptly stopped.

Volunteer usher David Cunningham reported a physical encounter while preparing the theater for a 2018 performance. Something invisible grabbed his arm with enough force to leave finger-shaped bruises on his forearm.

He immediately fled the building and refused to work alone after that incident. Cunningham’s bruises were photographed and documented by other staff members before they faded days later.

Actress Jennifer Walsh was rehearsing a 2019 production when she saw a woman in vintage clothing watching from the wings. The figure smiled at Walsh before walking directly through a solid wall and disappearing completely.

Walsh later identified the woman’s dress style as matching 1930s fashion after researching historical clothing. Her description perfectly matched previous accounts of “The Actress” spirit reported by other witnesses.

Projectionist Mark Stevens captured remarkable audio evidence during a solo shift in September 2021. His recording device picked up clear whispered conversations in an empty auditorium while he worked upstairs.

Stevens submitted this evidence to paranormal researchers who confirmed the voices were not present during recording. The words only became audible during playback, suggesting intelligent spiritual communication attempting to be heard.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

The Oklahoma Paranormal Research Society conducted a comprehensive investigation of the Constantine Theater in October 2018. Their team of six investigators spent twelve hours documenting activity throughout the entire building.

The group recorded over thirty distinct electronic voice phenomena during their overnight study. Several of these recordings contained full sentences, including one spirit identifying himself as Constantine Daniels.

Electromagnetic field meters registered significant spikes in the balcony section without any electrical explanation. These readings corresponded with team members reporting sudden cold spots and feelings of being watched.

Infrared cameras captured several shadow figures moving across the stage and through the audience seating area. These anomalies appeared on multiple cameras simultaneously, ruling out equipment malfunction or environmental factors.

The investigation team returned for a follow-up study in March 2019 with similar results. They concluded the Constantine Theater shows evidence of multiple intelligent hauntings rather than simple residual energy.

Ghost Adventures filmed a special episode featuring the Constantine Theater that aired in October 2020. Zak Bagans and his crew experienced intense paranormal activity during their investigation, including unexplained physical attacks.

During the televised investigation, crew members captured thermal imaging showing humanoid heat signatures where no living people stood. The footage also documented objects moving independently, including a chair sliding across the stage.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

The Constantine Theater is privately owned property and unauthorized entry is strictly prohibited by law. Trespassing charges will be filed against anyone attempting to enter outside official operating hours or without permission.

The building’s original sections contain aging infrastructure that poses potential safety hazards to unsupervised visitors. The catwalk area above the stage remains off-limits to public access due to structural concerns.

Visitors should remain aware of uneven flooring in certain backstage areas dating to the original construction. Several people have tripped over raised thresholds and gaps between original and renovated sections.

The building’s electrical system has been updated, but some original wiring remains behind sealed walls. Staff members are trained to monitor for any electrical issues that might compromise visitor safety.

Anyone experiencing intense paranormal activity should immediately notify theater staff for assistance. Several visitors have become disoriented or panicked during supernatural encounters and required help exiting the building.

Nearby Haunted Places

Gilcrease Museum – Haunted Museum in Tulsa, Oklahoma

📍 38.2 miles

The Hex House – Haunted Mansion in Tulsa, Oklahoma

📍 43.3 miles

Guthrie Scottish Rite Temple – Haunted Masonic Temple in Guthrie, Oklahoma

📍 80.7 miles

Stone Lion Inn – Haunted Bed & Breakfast in Guthrie, Oklahoma

📍 81.6 miles

Cherokee National Capitol – Haunted Government Building in Tahlequah, Oklahoma

📍 93.8 miles

Devil's Promenade / Hornet Spook Light – Haunted Rural Road in Joplin, Missouri

📍 97.1 miles