Historic Hotel Bethlehem – Haunted Hotel in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
Home > Haunted Places > State >
> Historic Hotel Bethlehem – Haunted Hotel in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
City:
State:
Full Address: Hotel Bethlehem, 437 Main St, Bethlehem, PA 18018, United States
Check In Google Map
Have you visited this place? Rate Your Experience!
The Historic Hotel Bethlehem is a charming hotel with a dark twist. It’s one of the oldest buildings in town, with a past that stretches back to the early 1800s.
Guests and staff have reported ghost sightings and unexplained activity for years. Many believe the hotel’s deep history is what keeps the spirits from moving on.
Historical Background
- Year Built: 1822
- Original Purpose: Hotel for travelers on the site of the former First House of Bethlehem (1741)
- Significant Events: The current hotel was built on land that once held a communal living house for Moravian settlers. This earlier building was used as a hospital during the Revolutionary War.
Soldiers died here. Many were buried nearby. The pain and suffering from that time are said to still linger in the air.
Paranormal Activity Summary
Strange footsteps echo down empty hallways. Lights flicker without warning.
Guests often feel cold spots or sudden chills, even on warm days. Some say objects move on their own—especially in guest rooms.
Several ghostly figures have been reported. The most famous include a woman in period dress, a former hotel staff member, and even a little boy.
By the way, have you visited this haunted place in Pennsylvania State? Devil’s Den – Haunted Battlefield Landmark in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania
Ghost Stories & Reports
One of the most well-known spirits is May Yohe, a stage actress born in the original house where the hotel now stands. She’s often seen in the lobby, smiling at guests before vanishing.
Room 932 is said to be a hotspot. Guests have heard knocks, whispers, and even laughter when no one is there.
Staff members have spotted a man in 18th-century clothing wandering the halls. He disappears when approached.
Another common tale involves a little boy who is seen playing near the elevators. Guests report hearing giggles, only to find no one there.
Speaking of haunted places, don’t forget to also check this place in Pennsylvania State? Mishler Theatre – Haunted Historic Theatre in Altoona, Pennsylvania
Most Haunted Spot Inside
The lobby and Room 932 are considered the most haunted areas. May Yohe’s spirit is often seen near the piano, and guests in Room 932 report the most intense experiences.
The paranormal doesn’t stop here—this haunted place might also interest you in Pennsylvania State? Van Sant Covered Bridge – Haunted Bridge in New Hope, Pennsylvania
Can You Visit?
- Open to the Public? Yes
- Entry Fee: None (standard hotel booking fees apply)
- Tour Availability: Ghost tours are sometimes offered during special events
- Photography Allowed? Yes
- Visiting Hours? Open 24/7 for hotel guests
Best Time to Visit
Autumn and winter seem to bring out the most ghostly activity. Guests say the spirits grow more active when the weather turns colder.
Paranormal Investigations & Findings
The hotel has been featured on multiple ghost shows and paranormal podcasts. Investigators often leave with recordings of strange voices and unexplained EMF spikes.
EVPs captured in Room 932 include soft singing and whispered names. Many believe these voices belong to May Yohe and other spirits tied to the building’s deep past.