Lake Bomoseen Ghost Sightings – Haunted Lake in Castleton, Vermont

Lake Bomoseen stretches across western Vermont like a dark mirror reflecting centuries of tragedy. This sprawling body of water near Castleton has earned a reputation as one of New England’s most haunted locations.

Visitors and locals alike report strange encounters along its shores and on its waters. The lake’s troubled history dates back hundreds of years to Native American conflicts and colonial-era deaths.

During summer months when tourists flock to the shoreline, whispered stories circulate through campgrounds and rental cabins. Many claim they’ve witnessed something unexplainable during their stay at Vermont’s largest lake.

The name “Bomoseen” itself carries an ominous weight in local folklore and tradition. Some say the word derives from an Abenaki chief who met his demise in these very waters.

Ghost stories have been documented here since the early 1800s when settlers first established permanent communities. The tales have only multiplied as more people explore the lake’s 2,400 acres each year.

Historical Background

Lake Bomoseen formed over 10,000 years ago during the last Ice Age’s glacial retreat. Indigenous peoples considered these waters sacred and warned of spirits dwelling beneath the surface.

The Abenaki tribes used the lake for fishing and travel for thousands of years. European settlers arrived in the mid-1700s and immediately began hearing stories about supernatural occurrences.

By 1776, the area witnessed violence during the Revolutionary War as British and colonial forces clashed. Several skirmishes occurred along the lake’s eastern shore resulting in numerous casualties.

The lake became a popular resort destination in the 1870s when wealthy families built estates. The Hydeville Hotel opened in 1880 and quickly gained notoriety for unexplained phenomena reported by guests.

A devastating boating accident in 1902 claimed the lives of seven people during a pleasure cruise. The vessel capsized near Neshobe Island and only two bodies were ever recovered from the depths.

Throughout the 1920s and 1930s, Lake Bomoseen served as a rumrunning route during Prohibition. Several gangsters allegedly met violent ends in the area and their bodies were dumped into the water.

The Slate History Museum archives document at least 47 drowning deaths between 1890 and 1950. Many of these incidents involved unexplained circumstances that authorities could never fully explain.

Paranormal Activity Summary

Phantom boats appear on the water during foggy evenings according to dozens of witnesses. These vessels glide silently across the surface before vanishing without explanation or trace.

Fishermen report their lines being tugged violently by unseen forces beneath the waves. The pulls feel deliberate and intelligent rather than resembling any natural fish movement.

Cold spots manifest suddenly along specific stretches of shoreline regardless of summer temperatures. These areas can be 20 to 30 degrees colder than surrounding locations just feet away.

Disembodied voices echo across the water late at night calling out names and warnings. Multiple witnesses have reported hearing someone shout “Turn back” or “Get out” near Neshobe Island.

Shadow figures walk along the beaches after dark moving with purposeful strides toward the water. They reach the shoreline and continue walking directly into the lake until they disappear completely.

Electronic equipment experiences frequent malfunctions in certain areas without any technical explanation or cause. Boat motors stall mysteriously near the location of the 1902 capsizing incident.

Swimmers feel hands grabbing at their legs and ankles in the deeper sections. The sensation is so realistic that many people panic and frantically swim to shore.

Unexplained lights dance several feet above the water’s surface during moonless nights. The orbs move in deliberate patterns and respond to human observers by approaching or retreating.

Ghost Stories & Reports

The most famous spirit is believed to be Chief Bomoseen himself from Abenaki legend. Local tradition claims he drowned in the lake during a battle with rival tribes in the 1600s.

His ghost allegedly appears as a tall figure in traditional dress standing on the water. Witnesses describe seeing him point toward the shore as if warning people away from danger.

A woman in white has been spotted near the ruins of the old Hydeville Hotel. She wanders the foundation stones calling out a name that sounds like “Marcus” or “Martin.”

Historical records show that a woman named Martha Hendricks died at the hotel in 1883. She fell down the main staircase after receiving news that her husband drowned in the lake.

Martha’s spirit seems trapped in an endless cycle of grief and searching for her lost spouse. People who encounter her report feeling overwhelming sadness that lingers for hours or even days.

The ghosts of seven victims from the 1902 boating disaster manifest near Neshobe Island. Witnesses describe seeing people in old-fashioned clothing standing in a group on the water itself.

These apparitions appear solid and real until observers approach closer for a better look. They vanish instantly leaving only ripples spreading outward across the otherwise calm surface.

A phantom child runs along the eastern shore crying for help in the early morning hours. The boy appears to be around eight years old wearing clothes from the 1940s era.

Research into historical drownings revealed that Tommy Ashford disappeared from a family picnic in 1947. The eight-year-old’s body was never recovered despite extensive searching for three weeks.

Local fisherman Dale Morrison documented an encounter in his journal dated September 1998. He described a transparent man in his boat asking for directions to Hydeville repeatedly.

The figure wore clothing consistent with the 1920s including a flat cap and suspenders. When Morrison tried to respond the man simply faded away leaving his boat rocking violently.

Campers at Bomoseen State Park frequently report hearing splashing sounds followed by desperate screaming. The sounds seem to come from multiple directions simultaneously creating disorientation and fear.

Most Haunted Spot

Neshobe Island stands as the epicenter of paranormal activity on Lake Bomoseen. This small island marks the location where the 1902 pleasure boat capsized taking seven souls.

Boaters who approach within 100 feet report their engines dying without mechanical explanation. Many describe feeling an overwhelming urge to turn around and leave the area immediately.

The northern point of the island hosts the highest concentration of shadow figure sightings. Multiple photography attempts in this location have produced strange mists and light anomalies.

Visitors who step onto the island itself describe feeling watched by hostile presences. Several people have reported being physically pushed or shoved by invisible hands near the shoreline.

The ruins of the old Hydeville Hotel foundation on the eastern shore ranks second. Martha’s ghost appears most frequently here especially during the anniversary of her death in November.

Can You Visit?

Lake Bomoseen is open to the public year-round for recreational activities and exploration. Bomoseen State Park provides the main access point with facilities and boat launches available.

Entry to the state park costs $4 per person for day use during operating season. Camping facilities are available from May through October with reservation fees ranging from $18 to $27.

No formal paranormal tours are currently offered by commercial operators in the area. However, local history groups occasionally organize evening walks discussing the lake’s haunted reputation and legends.

Photography is permitted throughout the park and on the lake without special permission required. Many paranormal investigators visit independently to conduct their own research and documentation.

The park is officially open from dawn to dusk for day visitors. Registered campers can remain on the grounds overnight which provides the best opportunity for experiences.

Boating on the lake is permitted with proper safety equipment and registration. Private boats can access Neshobe Island though no overnight camping is allowed there.

Best Time to Visit

Late autumn months from September through November produce the highest number of reported encounters. The anniversary of the 1902 boating disaster falls on September 14th each year.

Paranormal activity intensifies during foggy conditions which occur most frequently in early morning hours. The hours between 3:00 AM and 5:00 AM are considered the most active period.

Full moon nights bring increased sightings of the phantom boats and shadow figures. Local paranormal enthusiasts gather during these times hoping to witness unexplained phenomena.

The off-season months of October and November offer fewer crowds and better investigation opportunities. Colder temperatures seem to correlate with more frequent manifestations according to researchers.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

Jennifer Caldwell visited Lake Bomoseen with her family during July 2015 for a vacation. She photographed what appears to be a transparent figure standing on the water near their rental boat.

The image clearly shows a human-shaped form that wasn’t visible to anyone during the actual moment. Jennifer submitted the photograph to the New England Ghost Project which verified it hadn’t been altered.

Mark and Susan Reilly reported an encounter to the Rutland Herald newspaper in 2008. While fishing near Neshobe Island their boat engine died and the temperature plummeted dramatically.

They described seeing seven figures standing on the water approximately 50 feet from their boat. The apparitions remained visible for nearly three minutes before fading away into the mist.

Park Ranger Thomas Chen documented multiple incidents in official reports between 2010 and 2016. He noted 23 separate occasions when visitors reported unexplained phenomena requiring ranger response.

Chen personally witnessed shadow figures twice during evening patrols near the old hotel foundation. He described them as human-shaped but lacking any discernible features or clothing details.

Local historian Barbara Whitmore interviewed over 40 witnesses for her 2012 book about Vermont hauntings. She dedicated an entire chapter to Lake Bomoseen calling it the state’s most active location.

Whitmore’s research uncovered patterns connecting lunar phases with increased activity and witness reports. She also documented electromagnetic field anomalies measured by investigators at specific locations around the shoreline.

Local Legends & Myths

The Legend of Chief Bomoseen claims he placed a curse on the lake before drowning. According to tradition he declared the waters would claim one soul per year forever.

Statistical analysis of drowning incidents shows an unsettling pattern of at least one death annually. The pattern holds true for over 150 years of recorded history with rare exceptions.

Another legend speaks of hidden treasure buried on Neshobe Island by Prohibition-era gangsters. Those who search for it allegedly encounter violent spirits protecting the hidden cache.

Several treasure hunters have reported being attacked by invisible forces while metal detecting. One man required medical treatment in 2003 after receiving unexplained scratches and bruises.

The Woman in White is said to be searching for her wedding ring. Local belief holds that returning the ring would finally allow Martha Hendricks to rest.

Multiple people claim to have found antique rings along the eastern shore over the decades. Those who keep the rings report experiencing nightmares and feelings of being watched constantly.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

The Vermont Paranormal Research Team conducted three separate investigations between 2009 and 2014. They recorded numerous EVP phenomena including names, warnings, and what sounded like screaming.

Their electromagnetic field readings showed unusual spikes near Neshobe Island exceeding normal background levels. The team captured thermal imagery showing human-shaped cold spots moving independently along the shoreline.

New England Paranormal visited Lake Bomoseen in 2016 for their documentary series. They documented camera malfunctions, battery drains, and unexplained voices during their overnight investigation.

The group’s lead investigator reported being physically touched by an unseen presence. Multiple team members experienced the sensation of being watched throughout the investigation period.

Independent investigator Robert Chen spent 30 nights camping near the lake during 2017. His extensive documentation includes over 100 hours of audio recordings containing unexplained sounds and voices.

Chen’s analysis identified at least seven distinct voice patterns that repeat across multiple recordings. He believes these represent the seven victims from the 1902 boating accident.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

Visitors must respect state park hours and should never trespass on private property. Several shoreline areas belong to private landowners who prosecute trespassers to the full extent.

The lake itself can be dangerous with sudden depth changes and underwater hazards. Several drownings in recent years have been attributed to swimmers underestimating the conditions.

Neshobe Island is difficult to access and has no facilities or maintained trails. The terrain is rocky and uneven presenting significant injury risks especially during darkness.

Cell phone service is unreliable in many areas around the lake. Visitors should inform others of their plans and carry emergency supplies when investigating remote locations.

Never investigate alone as paranormal activity has reportedly caused panic attacks and disorientation. Buddy systems ensure someone can provide assistance if equipment fails or emergencies occur.

Nearby Haunted Places

The Sagamore Resort – Haunted Hotel in Bolton Landing, New York

📍 8.7 miles

Fort William Henry – Haunted Military Fort in Lake George, New York

📍 18.2 miles

Eddy House / Wilson Castle – Haunted Castle in Proctor, Vermont

📍 28.4 miles

Bowman Cemetery – Haunted Cemetery in Cuttingsville, Vermont

📍 33.6 miles

The Equinox Resort – Haunted Hotel in Manchester, Vermont

📍 40.1 miles

Bennington Battle Monument – Haunted Monument in Bennington, Vermont

📍 54.3 miles