Dartford Cemetery – Haunted Cemetery in Green Lake, Wisconsin

Dartford Cemetery sits quietly along County Road K in Green Lake, Wisconsin, surrounded by dense woods and rolling farmland. This small, unassuming burial ground dates back to the mid-1800s and has earned a reputation as one of Wisconsin’s most actively haunted locations.

Local residents and paranormal enthusiasts alike report strange occurrences within the cemetery’s iron gates. Tales of ghostly apparitions, unexplained lights, and eerie sounds have circulated through Green Lake County for generations.

The cemetery serves as the final resting place for early settlers and their families who established this region. Despite its peaceful appearance during daylight hours, something unsettling awakens after the sun goes down.

Visitors describe an overwhelming sense of being watched from the shadowy tree line. Many flee before completing their visit, convinced that something otherworldly dwells among the weathered headstones.

Historical Background

Dartford Cemetery was established around 1846 when German and Irish immigrants settled in Green Lake County. The small community of Dartford grew rapidly, and the cemetery became the primary burial ground for local families.

The cemetery contains approximately two hundred graves, many marked with simple fieldstones rather than elaborate monuments. Several graves date to the 1850s and 1860s, marking victims of disease outbreaks that ravaged the community.

A devastating cholera epidemic swept through Dartford in 1854, claiming the lives of forty-three residents within six weeks. Entire families perished during this outbreak, and many believe these tragic deaths left spiritual imprints on the land.

The cemetery also holds the remains of Civil War veterans who returned home wounded and broken. Captain William Hensley, who died in 1867 from war injuries, is buried beneath a distinctive marble obelisk.

By the 1920s, Dartford itself had become a ghost town as residents moved toward larger communities. The cemetery fell into disrepair, with many headstones toppling and markers becoming lost to time.

Local historical societies attempted restoration efforts in 1983, but workers reported strange incidents that caused several to quit. Tools would disappear and reappear in impossible locations, and crew members felt inexplicable cold spots even during summer.

Paranormal Activity Summary

The most commonly reported phenomenon at Dartford Cemetery involves mysterious orbs of light floating between gravestones. These lights appear as pale blue or greenish spheres that move with apparent intelligence and purpose.

Witnesses describe the orbs pausing at specific graves before drifting toward the cemetery’s northern section. The lights have been photographed numerous times, with images showing distinct luminous forms against the darkness.

Shadow figures constitute the second most frequent supernatural occurrence reported at this location. Multiple visitors have observed tall, dark silhouettes standing motionless near the oldest section of the cemetery.

These shadow entities appear to lack any distinguishing features or details. When approached or directly addressed, they vanish instantly, leaving witnesses deeply unsettled.

Disembodied voices and unexplained sounds plague visitors who venture into the cemetery after dusk. People report hearing whispered conversations in what sounds like German, the native language of many original settlers.

Children’s laughter echoes through the grounds despite no living children being present. This phenomenon particularly unnerves visitors, as the laughter often sounds playful at first before taking on disturbing qualities.

Electronic equipment malfunctions regularly within the cemetery boundaries, with fully charged batteries draining within minutes. Cameras, phones, and recording devices all experience mysterious failures that resolve once users exit the property.

Temperature anomalies occur throughout the year, with witnesses encountering pockets of frigid air during summer months. These cold spots move and seem to follow certain individuals, particularly near the grave of Sarah Mitchell.

Ghost Stories & Reports

The most infamous spirit haunting Dartford Cemetery is known simply as the Lady in White. She appears near a weathered headstone marking the grave of Elizabeth Dartford, who died in 1859 at age twenty-three.

Elizabeth perished during childbirth along with her infant daughter, both buried together beneath a shared marker. Witnesses describe seeing a woman in a flowing white dress wandering near this grave, often wringing her hands.

The Lady in White appears most frequently on foggy nights between September and November. She has been photographed multiple times, with images showing a translucent female figure near Elizabeth’s headstone.

Several visitors report that the Lady in White approached them directly, attempting to communicate. Her lips move as if speaking, but no sound emerges from her ghostly form.

Another prominent ghost is believed to be Captain William Hensley, the Civil War veteran. His spirit appears as a tall man in tattered Union Army uniform, standing at attention near his obelisk.

Captain Hensley’s ghost has been witnessed during early morning hours, particularly around Memorial Day and Veterans Day. He appears solid and lifelike until witnesses get within ten feet, at which point he fades away.

Local folklore tells of the Dartford Children, spirits of seven youngsters who died during the 1854 cholera outbreak. Their graves cluster together in the cemetery’s southwest corner, marked by small, weathered stones.

Visitors report hearing children’s voices singing old German nursery rhymes from this section. Some have seen small handprints appearing on car windows and foggy surfaces near these graves.

A particularly disturbing entity known as the Dark Watcher haunts the cemetery’s perimeter. This shadow figure stands over seven feet tall and appears along the tree line after midnight.

The Dark Watcher never enters the cemetery proper but observes visitors from the surrounding woods. Those who have encountered it describe overwhelming feelings of dread and malevolence emanating from the figure.

George Richter, a farmer who was murdered in 1892, is said to haunt his own grave. His killer was never identified, and some believe his restless spirit seeks justice for this unsolved crime.

Visitors to Richter’s grave report hearing angry male voices and experiencing violent pushing sensations. His headstone, a simple granite marker, is often found knocked over despite being reset multiple times.

Most Haunted Spot

The most intensely haunted location within Dartford Cemetery is the Mitchell family plot in the northeastern corner. This section contains the graves of Thomas and Sarah Mitchell along with their four children who died between 1862 and 1865.

Sarah Mitchell’s grave, marked by a cracked limestone headstone, serves as the epicenter of paranormal activity. Witnesses report seeing a woman’s face materializing in the stone itself when moonlight hits it at certain angles.

The area surrounding the Mitchell plot experiences dramatic temperature drops, sometimes reaching forty degrees colder than surrounding sections. Equipment failures happen most frequently here, with multiple paranormal investigators losing entire nights of footage.

Visitors report feeling physically ill when standing near Sarah’s grave, experiencing sudden nausea and dizziness. Several people have fainted at this exact spot, with no medical explanation for their collapse.

Can You Visit?

Dartford Cemetery is technically open to the public during daylight hours for genealogical research and respectful visitation. However, the cemetery is located on private property, and the landowner discourages visits after sunset.

There is no entry fee to visit the cemetery during permitted hours. Visitors should park along County Road K and walk approximately one hundred yards through a field path to reach the gates.

No official tours are conducted at Dartford Cemetery. Local paranormal groups occasionally organize investigations, but these require permission from the property owner in advance.

Photography is allowed during daylight visits for historical documentation purposes. Visitors should be respectful and avoid disturbing grave markers or leaving offerings that could attract wildlife.

Official visiting hours are dawn to dusk only. The Green Lake County Sheriff’s Department has issued trespassing citations to numerous individuals found at the cemetery after dark.

Best Time to Visit

Most paranormal activity at Dartford Cemetery occurs during autumn months, particularly October and early November. The anniversary of the 1854 cholera outbreak in October sees heightened supernatural phenomena according to local accounts.

Specific time periods between 2:00 AM and 4:00 AM yield the most dramatic encounters for those who risk visiting illegally. Full moon nights amplify activity levels, with multiple apparitions often appearing simultaneously during these periods.

Foggy conditions seem to correlate with increased sightings of the Lady in White and other entities. Early morning hours just before dawn also produce frequent encounters, particularly with Captain Hensley’s ghost.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

Jennifer Thompson, a Green Lake resident, visited Dartford Cemetery in October 2018 with her sister. She reported seeing a woman in period clothing standing near the Mitchell plot who vanished when they approached.

Thompson captured several photographs showing strange light anomalies and what appears to be a translucent figure. Her camera malfunctioned immediately after taking the last photo, and the battery was completely drained despite being fully charged.

David Kowalski, a paranormal investigator from Madison, conducted a overnight investigation in 2015 with proper permissions. His team recorded EVP sessions containing clear responses to questions in both English and German.

One recording captured a woman’s voice saying “meine kinder” (my children) followed by crying sounds. Kowalski’s equipment registered temperature drops of thirty-two degrees in localized areas with no natural explanation.

In 2019, teenagers from Green Lake High School entered the cemetery illegally after midnight on Halloween. Three of the five students reported being physically pushed by an unseen force near George Richter’s grave.

One student, Marcus Hill, suffered bruising on his chest and back consistent with handprints. The group fled after seeing multiple shadow figures emerging from the tree line and surrounding them.

Local historian Margaret Brennan visited in 2016 to document grave markers for county records. She experienced no paranormal activity during her afternoon visit but recorded strange voices on her phone’s video footage.

Upon reviewing the recordings later, Brennan heard children singing in German throughout her entire visit. No children were present during her documentation work, and she heard nothing unusual at the time.

Local Legends & Myths

Local legend claims that anyone who visits Elizabeth Dartford’s grave at midnight on the anniversary of her death will see her ghost. She supposedly appears to women in particular, especially those who are pregnant or have recently given birth.

According to folklore passed down through generations, Elizabeth’s ghost is searching for her lost child. Some versions claim she tries to steal living infants to replace the daughter she lost.

Another persistent legend involves a curse supposedly placed on the cemetery by a grieving father. After losing his entire family to cholera, Heinrich Schultz allegedly cursed anyone who disturbed the graves.

This curse supposedly manifests as severe misfortune befalling anyone who removes items or damages headstones. Several people who stole artifacts from the cemetery reportedly experienced accidents, illness, and financial ruin until returning the items.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

Wisconsin Paranormal Research conducted a formal investigation at Dartford Cemetery in September 2017. The team captured thermal imaging showing human-shaped cold spots moving independently through the grounds.

Their investigation yielded over thirty minutes of EVP recordings containing intelligent responses to questions. One particularly clear recording captured a male voice identifying himself as “William” near Captain Hensley’s grave.

Electromagnetic field detectors registered unusual spikes throughout the cemetery, particularly concentrated around the Mitchell family plot. These readings suggested the presence of energy sources with no identifiable origin.

The investigation team also photographed multiple full-body apparitions using infrared cameras. These images showed transparent human figures in period clothing that were invisible to the naked eye during filming.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

Visitors must understand that trespassing on the property after dusk is illegal and prosecuted. The Green Lake County Sheriff’s Department regularly patrols the area and will issue citations to nighttime trespassers.

The cemetery grounds are uneven with hidden holes and unstable headstones that pose trip hazards. Several visitors have suffered injuries from falls, particularly in the older sections where ground has settled unevenly.

Wildlife including coyotes, foxes, and occasional black bears inhabit the surrounding woods. Visitors should remain aware of their surroundings and avoid approaching or feeding any animals encountered on the property.

Cell phone reception is extremely limited in this rural location. Visitors should inform someone of their plans and expected return time before visiting the cemetery.

Nearby Haunted Places

Sheboygan Asylum Ruins – Haunted Asylum in Sheboygan, Wisconsin

📍 55.3 miles

St. Norbert College Old Main Hall – Haunted College Building in De Pere, Wisconsin

📍 60.4 miles

The Maribel Caves Hotel Ruins – Haunted Hotel in Maribel, Wisconsin

📍 65.9 miles

The Hamilton House Hotel – Haunted Hotel in Whitewater, Wisconsin

📍 71.3 miles

The Brumder Mansion – Haunted Mansion in Milwaukee, Wisconsin

📍 75.7 miles

The Pfister Hotel – Haunted Hotel in Milwaukee, Wisconsin

📍 77.4 miles