Wyoming Frontier Prison – Haunted Prison in Rawlins, Wyoming

The Wyoming Frontier Prison in Rawlins is one of the most chilling landmarks in the entire state.

Locals know it simply as the “Old Pen,” a hulking fortress of stone that held some of the West’s most dangerous men for eighty years.

Built at the turn of the century, the penitentiary earned a grim reputation for violence, disease, and death long before anyone spoke of ghosts.

Today visitors come for the history and stay for the hauntings. Footsteps echo down empty cell blocks, cold spots drift through the death house, and shadows move where no one stands.

It is easily one of the most talked about stops for anyone tracing the other haunted places in Wyoming, and its dark past makes it a magnet for paranormal seekers year round.

Historical Background

Construction on the Wyoming Frontier Prison began in the 1890s, and the facility opened its doors in 1901.

It served as the state penitentiary, replacing an older territorial prison and taking in convicts from across Wyoming.

The early years were brutal. The building had no running water and no electricity when inmates first arrived.

Wyoming winters were merciless, and the cell blocks offered almost no heat. Prisoners bundled together and still suffered through freezing nights.

Disease spread easily in those cramped, cold conditions, and the death toll climbed year after year.

Discipline was harsh by any measure. Guards used a punitive device known as the punishment pole, where inmates were restrained and disciplined for breaking the rules.

Over the course of its operation, the prison housed roughly 13,500 inmates before it finally closed in 1981.

Death was a constant companion inside these walls. More than 250 people are believed to have died here from disease, violence, and execution across the prison’s history.

Executions were carried out on site. Condemned men were first put to death by hanging on a mechanism called the Julian gallows, a device engineered so the prisoner’s own weight helped trigger the drop.

Later, the state installed a gas chamber, and executions shifted to that grim chamber in the prison’s final decades.

By the time the doors closed in 1981, the building was crumbling and far past its usefulness. It was spared from demolition and eventually reopened as a museum that preserves this difficult chapter of Wyoming history.

Paranormal Activity Summary

Visitors and staff report a wide range of strange phenomena throughout the Old Pen.

The most common are footsteps in empty hallways and faint voices whispering in the dark.

Sudden drops in temperature are frequent, even on warm days. People describe walking into a pocket of cold air with no source.

Doors that have not moved in years are said to slam shut on their own. Others swing open without a hand touching them.

Many guests speak of an overwhelming feeling of being watched. The sensation is strongest in the older cell blocks and near the execution area.

Some report a sudden heaviness in the chest, as though the air itself grows thick in certain rooms.

Full body apparitions are rarer, but a handful of witnesses insist they have seen figures in old prison clothing pass through the corridors.

Ghost Stories & Reports

Many people believe the prison’s past simply never left.

One of the most repeated stories involves a man in striped prison clothing seen walking through the main cell block. Witnesses say he vanishes the moment they look directly at him.

A few claim the striped figure keeps pace beside them for several steps before fading into the wall.

The name most often tied to the hauntings is Andrew Pixley, the last man executed at the prison. Pixley was put to death in the gas chamber in the 1960s for the murder of two young girls.

Guests claim his presence lingers near the old death house, and some say the air there feels heavy and wrong.

Others report hearing a woman crying somewhere inside the building, which unsettles guides because no women were ever imprisoned here.

Tour guides also share tales of a prankster spirit who laughs during tours and occasionally rattles or opens cell doors. Whether that story grew from real events or from years of retelling, it remains a favorite among visitors.

Most Haunted Spot

Ask any guide which room feels the worst, and most point to the gas chamber and the death house around it.

This is where the prison’s final executions took place, and the weight of that history seems to hang in the air.

People describe a sudden unease the moment they step inside. Some say they hear a faint hissing sound with no obvious source.

Others report strange odors and shadows that seem to shift just before the lights flicker.

Guides say small groups sometimes fall silent without meaning to, unwilling to break whatever hangs in the room.

The old solitary confinement cells run a close second. Guests often refuse to stay inside them for more than a moment.

Can You Visit?

Yes. The Wyoming Frontier Prison now operates as a museum in downtown Rawlins.

Staff offer daytime historical tours that walk guests through the cell blocks, the punishment areas, and the execution facilities.

Separate ghost and paranormal tours are also offered, and these lean into the darker side of the prison’s story.

Admission is modest, typically in the range of a low ticket price for adults, with tour options priced above that. Hours shift with the season, so it is best to confirm before you drive out.

Photography is generally allowed on tours, which makes it a rewarding stop for anyone working through a list of the most haunted prisons in America.

Best Time to Visit

Fall is the most popular season to explore the Old Pen.

October in particular brings expanded ghost tours and a heavier schedule of night visits.

Many investigators believe the late evening hours produce the strongest activity, when the building is quiet and the crowds have gone.

Winter visits are possible but harder. Wyoming cold and icy footing make some areas difficult to reach safely.

First-Hand Accounts & Eyewitness Reports

Over the years, countless guests have shared unsettling experiences from inside the walls.

One visitor described feeling almost paralyzed with fear while standing inside a solitary confinement cell, unable to explain the dread.

A former tour guide recalled hearing a voice shout to be let out from a cell that turned out to be empty.

Another guest reported a firm tug on their sleeve while standing alone at the end of a cell block.

Investigators have described sudden equipment failures, batteries that drain in minutes, and recorders that pick up voices no one heard in the moment.

Photographs taken in the execution area sometimes show unexplained shapes and light anomalies that guests cannot account for afterward.

Local Legends & Myths

Like most old prisons, the Old Pen has gathered its share of legend over the decades.

Some stories claim the punishment pole and the gas chamber hold a kind of residual imprint, replaying the suffering that happened there.

One persistent tale holds that a desperate inmate set himself ablaze in his cell, and that the memory of that act still clings to the block.

The crying woman heard in the building has inspired several competing local tales, though none can be verified and most guides treat it as folklore.

Other legends exaggerate the number of deaths or invent lurid details that the documented record does not support.

The truth of the place is grim enough on its own. The real history of cold, disease, and execution needs no embellishment to unsettle a visitor.

Paranormal Investigations & Findings

The prison’s reputation has drawn paranormal investigators and television crews from across the country.

Ghost hunting teams have filmed here over the years, documenting cold spots, unexplained audio, and unusual electromagnetic readings in the cell blocks.

Investigators frequently focus on the death house, the gas chamber, and the solitary cells, the areas guests report as the most active.

Audio specialists point to the death house as the source of their most convincing recordings, faint words captured on playback that no one heard live.

Results vary from visit to visit, which is common at large sites like this one. Some nights produce little, while others yield recordings that puzzle even seasoned researchers.

Anyone planning their own investigation should come prepared, and our ghost hunting equipment guide covers the recorders, meters, and cameras that work best in a setting like this.

Safety Warnings & Legal Restrictions

The Wyoming Frontier Prison is a historic building, and parts of it show their age.

Some areas close during winter due to ice and unstable stairs, and guides may reroute tours for safety.

Visitors are asked to stay with their group at all times, especially near the older infirmary and execution areas.

Trespassing outside of official tours is not permitted. The site is managed property, and after hours access is strictly off limits.

Respect the building, follow your guide, and treat the space as the somber place of death that it truly is.

Nearby Haunted Places

The Historic Virginian Hotel – Haunted Hotel in Medicine Bow, Wyoming

📍 54.1 miles

Miner's Delight – Haunted Ghost Town in Fremont County, Wyoming

📍 89.6 miles

South Pass City – Haunted Mining Town in South Pass City, Wyoming

📍 92.4 miles

Warren Air Force Base – Haunted Military Base in Cheyenne, Wyoming

📍 130.6 miles

Stanley Hotel – Haunted Hotel in Estes Park, Colorado

📍 132.4 miles

Atlas Theatre – Haunted Theater in Cheyenne, Wyoming

📍 133.7 miles